Eamer Gilgamesh, Gibson Jennifer A, Gillis Chelsia, Hsu Amy T, Krawczyk Marian, MacDonald Emily, Whitlock Reid, Khadaroo Rachel G
Department of Surgery, 2D, Walter C Mackenzie Health Sciences Centre, University of Alberta, 8440-112 Street, Edmonton, AB, T6G 2B7, Canada.
School of Public Health, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada.
BMC Anesthesiol. 2017 Jul 24;17(1):99. doi: 10.1186/s12871-017-0390-7.
Preoperative frailty predicts adverse postoperative outcomes. Despite the advantages of incorporating frailty assessment into surgical settings, there is limited research on surgical healthcare professionals' use of frailty assessment for perioperative care.
Healthcare professionals caring for patients enrolled at a Canadian teaching hospital were surveyed to assess their perceptions of frailty, as well as attitudes towards and practices for frail patients. The survey contained open-ended and 5-point Likert scale questions. Responses were compared across professions using independent sample t-tests and correlations between survey items were analyzed.
Nurses and allied health professionals were more likely than surgeons to think frailty should play a role in planning a patient's care (nurses vs. surgeons p = 0.008, allied health vs. surgeons p = 0.014). Very few respondents (17.5%) reported that they 'always used' a frailty assessment tool. Results from qualitative data analysis identified four main barriers to frailty assessment: institutional, healthcare system, professional knowledge, and patient/family barriers.
Across all disciplines, the lack of knowledge about frailty issues was a prominent barrier to the use of frailty assessments in practice, despite clinicians' understanding that frailty affects their patients' outcomes. Confidence in frailty assessment tool use through education and addressing barriers to implementation may increase use and improve patient care. Healthcare professionals agree that frailty assessments should play a role in perioperative care. However, few perform them in practice. Lack of knowledge about frailty is a key barrier in the use of frailty assessments and the majority of respondents agreed that they would benefit from further training.
术前虚弱状态可预测不良术后结局。尽管将虚弱评估纳入手术环境有诸多优势,但关于外科医疗保健专业人员在围手术期护理中使用虚弱评估的研究有限。
对在一家加拿大教学医院就诊的患者的医护人员进行调查,以评估他们对虚弱的看法,以及对虚弱患者的态度和做法。该调查包含开放式和5分制李克特量表问题。使用独立样本t检验比较不同专业的回答,并分析调查项目之间的相关性。
护士和专职医疗人员比外科医生更倾向于认为虚弱应在规划患者护理中发挥作用(护士与外科医生相比,p = 0.008;专职医疗人员与外科医生相比,p = 0.014)。很少有受访者(17.5%)报告他们“总是使用”虚弱评估工具。定性数据分析结果确定了虚弱评估的四个主要障碍:机构、医疗保健系统、专业知识和患者/家庭障碍。
在所有学科中,尽管临床医生理解虚弱会影响患者的结局,但对虚弱问题缺乏了解是在实践中使用虚弱评估的一个突出障碍。通过教育增强对虚弱评估工具使用的信心并消除实施障碍,可能会增加其使用并改善患者护理。医疗保健专业人员一致认为虚弱评估应在围手术期护理中发挥作用。然而,在实践中很少有人进行评估。对虚弱缺乏了解是使用虚弱评估的关键障碍,大多数受访者同意他们将从进一步培训中受益。