Raimes S A, Smirniotis V, Wheldon E J, Venables C W, Johnston I D
Lancet. 1986 Oct 11;2(8511):851-3. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(86)92882-5.
Truncal vagotomy and drainage is still the commonest operation for duodenal ulcer in the United Kingdom, despite its known association with diarrhoea. The frequency and severity of diarrhoea were compared in 102 randomly selected men 10 or more years after truncal vagotomy and pyloroplasty (TVP) and a control group of 62 men taking long-term maintenance cimetidine treatment 2 or more years after healing of duodenal ulcer. 53% of the TVP group still had diarrhoea attacks compared with only 7% of the cimetidine group (p less than 0.001). Of the TVP patients, 11% had continuous diarrhoea and a further 22% at least one attack a week. 24% were displeased with the change in bowel function, and 8% complained that diarrhoea still seriously affected their lives. This side-effect is unacceptable and truncal vagotomy should now be avoided whenever possible.
在英国,尽管已知迷走神经干切断术和引流术与腹泻有关,但它仍是十二指肠溃疡最常见的手术方式。对102例随机选取的男性进行了比较,这些男性在接受迷走神经干切断术和幽门成形术(TVP)10年或更长时间后,与62例在十二指肠溃疡愈合后接受2年或更长时间长期维持西咪替丁治疗的男性对照组相比,腹泻的频率和严重程度。TVP组53%的患者仍有腹泻发作,而西咪替丁组只有7%(p<0.001)。在TVP患者中,11%有持续性腹泻,另有22%每周至少发作一次。24%的患者对肠道功能的改变不满意,8%的患者抱怨腹泻仍严重影响他们的生活。这种副作用是不可接受的,现在应尽可能避免进行迷走神经干切断术。