The National Institute for Health Research Collaboration for Leadership in Applied Health Research and Care West (NIHR CLAHRC West) at University Hospitals Bristol NHS Foundation Trust, Bristol, UK.
School of Social and Community Medicine,University of Bristol, Bristol, UK.
Sex Transm Infect. 2018 Mar;94(2):88-92. doi: 10.1136/sextrans-2017-053322. Epub 2017 Aug 4.
Domestic violence and abuse (DVA) is a major clinical challenge and public health issue. Sexual health services are an important potential site of DVA intervention. The (ADViSE) intervention aimed to improve identification and management of DVA in sexual healthcare settings and is a modified version of the (IRIS) general practice programme. Our qualitative evaluation aimed to explore the experiences of staff participating in an IRIS ADViSE pilot.
Interviews were conducted with 17 sexual health clinic staff and DVA advocate workers. Interviews were audio recorded, transcribed, anonymised and analysed thematically.
Staff prioritised enquiring about DVA and tailored their style of enquiry to the perceived characteristics of patients, current workload and individual clinical judgements. Responding to disclosures of abuse was divided between perceived low-risk cases (with quick onwards referral) and high-risk cases (requiring deployment of institution safeguarding procedures), which were viewed as time consuming and could create tensions with patients. Ongoing training and feedback, commissioner recognition, adequate service-level agreements and reimbursements are required to ensure sustainability and wider implementation of IRIS ADViSE.
Challenges of delivering and sustaining IRIS ADViSE included the varied styles of enquiry, as well as tensions and additional time pressure arising from disclosure of abuse. These can be overcome by modifying initial training, providing regular updates and stronger recognition (and resources) at policy and commissioning levels.
家庭暴力和虐待(DVA)是一个主要的临床挑战和公共卫生问题。性健康服务是干预家庭暴力的一个重要潜在场所。(ADViSE)干预旨在改善性保健环境中对家庭暴力和虐待的识别和管理,是一般实践计划(IRIS)的修改版本。我们的定性评估旨在探讨参与 IRIS ADViSE 试点的工作人员的经验。
对 17 名性健康诊所工作人员和家庭暴力倡导者进行了访谈。采访进行了录音、转录、匿名化,并进行了主题分析。
工作人员优先询问家庭暴力问题,并根据患者的感知特征、当前工作量和个人临床判断调整询问方式。对虐待行为的披露分为低风险病例(快速转介)和高风险病例(需要部署机构保护程序),这些病例被认为既费时又会与患者产生紧张关系。需要持续的培训和反馈、专员认可、足够的服务级别协议和报销,以确保 IRIS ADViSE 的可持续性和更广泛的实施。
提供和维持 IRIS ADViSE 面临的挑战包括不同的询问方式,以及因虐待行为的披露而产生的紧张和额外的时间压力。可以通过修改初始培训、提供定期更新以及在政策和委托层面提供更强的认可(和资源)来克服这些问题。