Hoorntje Edgar T, Bollen Ilse A, Barge-Schaapveld Daniela Q, van Tienen Florence H, Te Meerman Gerard J, Jansweijer Joeri A, van Essen Anthonie J, Volders Paul G, Constantinescu Alina A, van den Akker Peter C, van Spaendonck-Zwarts Karin Y, Oldenburg Rogier A, Marcelis Carlo L, van der Smagt Jasper J, Hennekam Eric A, Vink Aryan, Bootsma Marianne, Aten Emmelien, Wilde Arthur A, van den Wijngaard Arthur, Broers Jos L, Jongbloed Jan D, van der Velden Jolanda, van den Berg Maarten P, van Tintelen J Peter
For the author affiliations, please see the Appendix.
Circ Cardiovasc Genet. 2017 Aug;10(4). doi: 10.1161/CIRCGENETICS.116.001631.
Interpretation of missense variants can be especially difficult when the variant is also found in control populations. This is what we encountered for the c.992G>A (p.(Arg331Gln)) variant. Therefore, to evaluate the effect of this variant, we combined an evaluation of clinical data with functional experiments and morphological studies.
Clinical data of 23 probands and 35 family members carrying this variant were retrospectively collected. A time-to-event analysis was performed to compare the course of the disease with carriers of other mutations. Myocardial biopsies were studied with electron microscopy and by measuring force development of the sarcomeres. Morphology of the nuclear envelope was assessed with immunofluorescence on cultured fibroblasts. The phenotype in probands and family members was characterized by atrioventricular conduction disturbances (61% and 44%, respectively), supraventricular arrhythmias (69% and 52%, respectively), and dilated cardiomyopathy (74% and 14%, respectively). LMNA p.(Arg331Gln) carriers had a significantly better outcome regarding the composite end point (malignant ventricular arrhythmias, end-stage heart failure, or death) compared with carriers of other pathogenic mutations. A shared haplotype of 1 Mb around suggested a common founder. The combined logarithm of the odds score was 3.46. Force development in membrane-permeabilized cardiomyocytes was reduced because of decreased myofibril density. Structural nuclear -associated envelope abnormalities, that is, blebs, were confirmed by electron microscopy and immunofluorescence microscopy.
Clinical, morphological, functional, haplotype, and segregation data all indicate that LMNA p.(Arg331Gln) is a pathogenic founder mutation with a phenotype reminiscent of other mutations but with a more benign course.
当错义变异也在对照人群中被发现时,对其进行解读可能会特别困难。我们在c.992G>A(p.(Arg331Gln))变异中就遇到了这种情况。因此,为了评估该变异的影响,我们将临床数据评估与功能实验及形态学研究相结合。
回顾性收集了23名携带此变异的先证者和35名家庭成员的临床数据。进行了事件发生时间分析,以将疾病进程与其他突变携带者进行比较。通过电子显微镜和测量肌节的力产生来研究心肌活检样本。在培养的成纤维细胞上用免疫荧光评估核膜的形态。先证者和家庭成员的表型特征为房室传导障碍(分别为61%和44%)、室上性心律失常(分别为69%和52%)以及扩张型心肌病(分别为74%和14%)。与其他致病突变携带者相比,LMNA p.(Arg331Gln)携带者在复合终点(恶性室性心律失常、终末期心力衰竭或死亡)方面的结局明显更好。约1 Mb的共享单倍型提示存在共同的奠基者。优势对数分数的总和为3.46。由于肌原纤维密度降低,膜通透心肌细胞中的力产生减少。通过电子显微镜和免疫荧光显微镜证实了与核相关的包膜结构异常,即泡状结构。
临床、形态学、功能、单倍型和分离数据均表明,LMNA p.(Arg331Gln)是一种致病的奠基者突变,其表型让人联想到其他突变,但病程更为良性。