McCusker Jane, Yaffe Mark, Sussman Tamara, Cole Martin, Sewitch Maida, Strumpf Erin, Freeman Ellen, Lambert Sylvie, de Raad Manon
Centre de recherche de St. Mary, Montréal, Canada ; Département d'épidémiologie, biostatistique et santé au travail, Université McGill, Montréal, Canada.
Département de médecine familiale, Centre hospitalier de St. Mary, Montréal, Canada ; Département de médecine de famille, Université McGill, Montréal, Canada.
Sante Ment Que. 2017 Spring;42(1):273-288.
Objectives A research group based at St. Mary's Research Centre, St. Mary's Hospital, Montreal, has conducted a research program over the past two decades that aims to inform improvements in the management of depression in primary care and general medical settings, among older adults. This paper reviews the findings from this research program, discusses the findings in the context of other research, and highlights the implications for practice and health policy.Methods Narrative review and synthesis of 25 published articles, that included: 4 systematic reviews, 10 observational studies, 9 intervention trials, and 2 consensus conference reports.Results The results pertain to 4 research areas: detection of depression in primary care and general medical settings; collaborative care of depression; depression self-care interventions; and the role of family and friends in supporting depression self-care interventions.Conclusions We propose six recommendations for improving the management of depression in the target population. 1) Depression detection and treatment can be improved through collaborative care models that involve primary care physicians, mental health specialists and non-physician mental health workers who are trained to assist with the detection of depression, with the delivery of brief, low-intensity psychological interventions and with self-care support. More research and evaluation are necessary to determine the factors that enhance the effectiveness, cost-efficiency, and consumer-centeredness of these interventions. 2) Supported depression self-care (and other low-intensity interventions such as short problem-solving therapy) offered by telephone or via internet, either as part of collaborative or usual care are feasible treatment options but more research is necessary to determine their effectiveness in different clinical populations. Some populations (e.g., those aged 75 and over, with visual and/or mild cognitive impairment) are likely to need greater or face-to-face support. 3) As most family physicians are unlikely to have the necessary time or interest to support depression self-care interventions, other sustainable programmatic contexts are needed for delivery of these interventions. Options include: nurses or other mental health workers in multidisciplinary family medicine groups; regional mental health programs; and voluntary organizations dedicated to assisting in the management of chronic illnesses. Research is needed on the feasibility and effectiveness of using peer support workers or volunteers to provide coaching of depression self-care interventions. 4) Involvement of family or friends in depression self-care may improve outcomes (e.g., dyadic interventions) but further research is necessary. 5) Further research should explore the potential of depression self-care interventions to prevent major depression and in depression relapse prevention in this population.
目标 蒙特利尔圣玛丽医院圣玛丽研究中心的一个研究小组在过去二十年开展了一项研究项目,旨在为改善老年人初级保健和普通医疗环境中抑郁症的管理提供依据。本文回顾了该研究项目的结果,在其他研究背景下讨论了这些结果,并强调了对实践和卫生政策的影响。
方法 对25篇已发表文章进行叙述性综述和综合分析,其中包括:4篇系统评价、10项观察性研究、9项干预试验和2份共识会议报告。
结果 结果涉及4个研究领域:初级保健和普通医疗环境中抑郁症的检测;抑郁症的协作护理;抑郁症自我护理干预;以及家人和朋友在支持抑郁症自我护理干预中的作用。
结论 我们针对改善目标人群抑郁症管理提出六项建议。1) 通过协作护理模式可以改善抑郁症的检测和治疗,该模式涉及初级保健医生、心理健康专家和经过培训以协助抑郁症检测、提供简短低强度心理干预和自我护理支持的非医生心理健康工作者。需要更多的研究和评估来确定提高这些干预措施有效性、成本效益和以消费者为中心的因素。2) 通过电话或互联网提供的支持性抑郁症自我护理(以及其他低强度干预措施,如简短的解决问题疗法),无论是作为协作护理还是常规护理的一部分,都是可行的治疗选择,但需要更多研究来确定其在不同临床人群中的有效性。一些人群(例如75岁及以上、有视力和/或轻度认知障碍的人群)可能需要更多或面对面的支持。3) 由于大多数家庭医生不太可能有必要的时间或兴趣来支持抑郁症自我护理干预,因此需要其他可持续的项目背景来提供这些干预措施。选择包括:多学科家庭医学团队中的护士或其他心理健康工作者;区域心理健康项目;以及致力于协助慢性病管理的志愿组织。需要研究使用同伴支持工作者或志愿者提供抑郁症自我护理干预指导的可行性和有效性。4) 家人或朋友参与抑郁症自我护理可能会改善结果(例如二元干预),但需要进一步研究。5) 进一步的研究应探索抑郁症自我护理干预在预防该人群重度抑郁症和抑郁症复发方面的潜力。