Halldin Cara N, Hale Janet M, Blackley David J, Laney A Scott
Respiratory Health Division, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Morgantown, West Virginia, USA.
BMJ Open. 2017 Aug 11;7(8):e015876. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-015876.
The National Institute for Occupation Safety and Health-administered Coal Workers' Health Surveillance Program (CWHSP) provides radiographic pneumoconiosis screening for US coal miners. Radiographs are classified by readers according to International Labour Office criteria. In addition to pneumoconiotic parenchymal and pleural lung abnormalities, readers document radiographic features of importance (other symbols). Other symbols are not meant to imply a diagnosis or interpretation but are relevant as they provide information beyond a pneumoconiosis classification for features related to dust exposure and other aetiologies. Our objective was to summarise other symbol data from 48 years of CWHSP participants.
Chest radiograph classifications obtained from CWHSP participants between July 1968 and July 2016 were analysed. Any 'other symbol' indication from any of the readings were counted. Frequencies were tabulated by individual reader and those identified by any reader.
Of the 469 922 radiographs included in this study, nearly 15% had at least one reader identify a radiographic feature of importance. The most commonly identified other symbol was cancer (excluding mesothelioma) (6.83%), followed by emphysema (1.68%). Some features were rarely identified over the 48 years of data collection such as rheumatoid pneumoconiosis (n=46), pneumothorax (n=32), mesothelioma (n=12) and rounded atelectasis (n=4).
This is the largest study to date describing radiographic features of importance as part of routine chest radiographic surveillance. While these symbols are not diagnostic they can be used to describe features associated with dust exposure. One of the most commonly identified radiographic features in our population is emphysema which is associated with respirable dust exposure. These results can be compared with other dust exposed populations.
美国国家职业安全与健康研究所管理的煤矿工人健康监测项目(CWHSP)为美国煤矿工人提供尘肺病的X光筛查。X光片由阅片者根据国际劳工组织的标准进行分类。除了尘肺病的肺实质和胸膜异常外,阅片者还记录重要的X光特征(其他符号)。其他符号并非用于暗示诊断或解读,但因其提供了尘肺病分类之外与粉尘暴露及其他病因相关特征的信息而具有相关性。我们的目的是总结CWHSP 48年参与者的其他符号数据。
分析了1968年7月至2016年7月期间CWHSP参与者的胸部X光片分类。统计每次阅片中出现的任何“其他符号”指示。按个体阅片者以及任何阅片者识别出的情况列出频率。
本研究纳入的469922张X光片中,近15%至少有一位阅片者识别出重要的X光特征。最常识别出的其他符号是癌症(不包括间皮瘤)(6.83%),其次是肺气肿(1.68%)。在48年的数据收集过程中发现一些特征很少见,如类风湿性尘肺病(n = 46)、气胸(n = 32)、间皮瘤(n = 12)和圆形肺不张(n = 4)。
这是迄今为止描述作为常规胸部X光监测一部分的重要X光特征的最大规模研究。虽然这些符号不能用于诊断,但可用于描述与粉尘暴露相关的特征。我们研究人群中最常识别出的X光特征之一是肺气肿,它与可吸入粉尘暴露有关。这些结果可与其他粉尘暴露人群进行比较。