Amachawadi R G, Purvis T J, Lubbers B V, Homm J W, Maxwell C L, Nagaraja T G
J Anim Sci. 2017 Aug;95(8):3425-3434. doi: 10.2527/jas.2016.1198.
Holstein steers raised for beef production consistently have a higher prevalence and more severe form of liver abscesses than cattle of beef breeds. A study was conducted to compare bacterial flora of liver abscesses collected from multiple abattoirs from 4 groups of cattle, arranged in a 2 × 2 factorial design, consisting of crossbred cattle and Holstein steers, and each group fed a finishing diet supplemented with or without tylosin. A total of 383 liver abscess samples, consisting of 94 and 81 from crossbred cattle and 89 and 119 from Holstein steers fed finishing diets with or without tylosin, respectively, were subjected for anaerobic and aerobic bacterial isolations. The minimum inhibitory concentrations (MIC) of tylosin to the predominant bacterial species were determined. The likelihood chi-square test was performed to assess unadjusted differences in bacterial prevalence proportions between the 2 types of cattle (crossbred and Holstein steers) and feed type (tylosin or no tylosin). There was no interaction between cattle type and tylosin inclusion on the prevalence of any of the bacterial species isolated. Liver abscesses from Holstein steers yielded a higher total number of isolates compared to liver abscesses from crossbred cattle (1060 vs. 788). subsp. was isolated from all abscesses. The prevalence of subsp. was 19.1% and was not affected by the cattle type or tylosin. The prevalence of was higher ( < 0.01) in crossbred cattle (73.7%) compared to Holstein steers (29.8%). Also, the prevalence of was higher in abscesses from tylosin-fed (66.1%) cattle than no tylosin-fed cattle (35%). The overall prevalence of was 25.3% and was similar ( = 0.58) between cattle type, but the prevalence was lower ( < 0.01) in tylosin-fed (16.9%) compared to no tylosin-fed group (33%). Mean MIC of tylosin for and were similar across both cattle types and tylosin inclusion. Although bacterial flora of liver abscesses from Holstein steers appeared to be more diverse than that of crossbred cattle, there was no difference in the prevalence of the and and in fact, prevalence of was higher in crossbred than Holstein steers. Therefore, the difference in bacterial flora is not the likely reason for higher prevalence and severity of liver abscesses in Holstein steers than crossbred beef cattle.
用于牛肉生产的荷斯坦公牛,其肝脓肿的患病率一直高于肉牛品种的牛,且肝脓肿的形式更为严重。本研究进行了一项比较,从4组牛的多个屠宰场收集肝脓肿的细菌菌群,采用2×2析因设计,包括杂交牛和荷斯坦公牛,每组饲喂补充或未补充泰乐菌素的育肥牛日粮。总共383份肝脓肿样本,分别来自杂交牛94份和81份,以及饲喂或未饲喂泰乐菌素育肥牛日粮的荷斯坦公牛89份和119份,进行厌氧和好氧细菌分离。测定了泰乐菌素对主要细菌种类的最低抑菌浓度(MIC)。进行似然卡方检验,以评估两种牛(杂交牛和荷斯坦公牛)和饲料类型(泰乐菌素或无泰乐菌素)之间细菌患病率比例的未经调整差异。牛的类型和泰乐菌素添加对任何分离出的细菌种类的患病率均无相互作用。与杂交牛的肝脓肿相比,荷斯坦公牛的肝脓肿分离出的菌株总数更多(1060株对788株)。从所有脓肿中均分离出亚种。亚种的患病率为19.1%,不受牛的类型或泰乐菌素的影响。与荷斯坦公牛(29.8%)相比,杂交牛中该菌的患病率更高(P<0.01)(73.7%)。此外,在饲喂泰乐菌素的牛(66.1%)的脓肿中,该菌的患病率高于未饲喂泰乐菌素的牛(35%)。该菌的总体患病率为25.3%,在不同牛的类型之间相似(P = 0.58),但在饲喂泰乐菌素的组(16.9%)中,其患病率低于未饲喂泰乐菌素的组(33%)。两种牛的类型和泰乐菌素添加情况下,泰乐菌素对该菌和另一菌的平均MIC相似。尽管荷斯坦公牛肝脓肿的细菌菌群似乎比杂交牛的更多样化,但两种菌以及某菌的患病率并无差异,实际上,杂交牛中某菌的患病率高于荷斯坦公牛。因此,细菌菌群的差异不太可能是荷斯坦公牛比杂交肉牛肝脓肿患病率更高、病情更严重的原因。