Eriksson Leif, Bergström Anna, Hoa Dinh Thi Phuong, Nga Nguyen Thu, Eldh Ann Catrine
International Maternal and Child Health (IMCH), Department of Women's and Children's Health, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden.
Departmant of Public Health and Caring Sciences, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden.
PLoS One. 2017 Aug 14;12(8):e0182626. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0182626. eCollection 2017.
In a previous trial in Vietnam, a facilitation strategy to secure evidence-based practice in primary care resulted in reduced neonatal mortality over a period of three years. While little is known as to what ensures sustainability in the implementation of community-based strategies, the aim of this study was to investigate factors promoting or hindering implementation, and sustainability of knowledge implementation strategies, by means of the former Neonatal Knowledge Into Practice (NeoKIP) trial.
In 2014 we targeted all levels in the Vietnamese healthcare system: six individual interviews with representatives at national, provincial and district levels, and six focus group discussions with representatives at the commune level. The interviews were transcribed verbatim, translated to English, and analysed using inductive and deductive thematic analysis.
To achieve successful implementation and sustained effect of community-based knowledge implementation strategies, engagement of leaders and key stakeholders at all levels of the healthcare system is vital-prior to, during and after a project. Implementation and sustainability require thorough needs assessment, tailoring of the intervention, and consideration of how to attain and manage funds. The NeoKIP trial was characterised by a high degree of engagement at the primary healthcare system level. Further, three years post trial, maternal and neonatal care was still high on the agenda for healthcare workers and leaders, even though primary aspects such as stakeholder engagement at all levels, and funding had been incomplete or lacking.
The current study illustrates factors to support successful implementation and sustain effects of community-based strategies in projects in low- and middle-income settings; some but not all factors were represented during the post-NeoKIP era. Most importantly, trials in this and similar contexts require deliberate management throughout and beyond the project lifetime, and engagement of key stakeholders, in order to promote and sustain knowledge implementation.
在越南此前进行的一项试验中,一项旨在确保基层医疗中循证实践的促进策略在三年时间里降低了新生儿死亡率。虽然对于如何确保基于社区的策略得以持续实施知之甚少,但本研究的目的是通过之前的“新生儿知识转化为实践”(NeoKIP)试验,调查促进或阻碍知识实施策略的实施及可持续性的因素。
2014年,我们针对越南医疗体系的各个层面:对国家、省和地区层面的代表进行了6次个人访谈,并与公社层面的代表进行了6次焦点小组讨论。访谈内容逐字记录,翻译成英文,并采用归纳和演绎主题分析法进行分析。
为实现基于社区的知识实施策略的成功实施和持续效果,医疗体系各级领导和关键利益相关者在项目之前、期间和之后的参与至关重要。实施和可持续性需要进行全面的需求评估、调整干预措施,并考虑如何获取和管理资金。NeoKIP试验的特点是基层医疗体系层面的参与度很高。此外,试验三年后,孕产妇和新生儿护理仍然是医护人员和领导议程上的重要事项,尽管各级利益相关者参与和资金等主要方面并不完整或缺乏。
本研究阐明了支持中低收入环境下项目中基于社区的策略成功实施并维持效果的因素;在NeoKIP试验后的时代,部分但并非所有因素都有所体现。最重要的是,在这种及类似背景下的试验在项目整个周期及之后都需要精心管理,并让关键利益相关者参与进来,以促进和维持知识的实施。