O'Connor Kieron, Lavoie Marc, Desaulniers Benoît, Audet Jean-Sébastien
University of Montreal.
Research Center of the Montreal Institute of Mental Health.
J Clin Psychol. 2018 Mar;74(3):273-285. doi: 10.1002/jclp.22501. Epub 2017 Aug 16.
Body-focused repetitive behaviors (BFRBs), such as hair pulling, skin picking, and nail biting, are repetitive, destructive, and nonfunctional habits that cause significant distress. Separate BFRBs form a cohesive group and could be assessed as part of the Tourette/tic spectrum or obsessive-compulsive spectrum of disorders. The treatment of choice is either antidepressant or behavioral treatment, both of which have shown effectiveness. The cognitive psychophysiological (CoPs) model focuses on the tension and emotional build up that triggers habits by addressing cognitive-behavioral, emotional and psychophysiological processes preceding onset rather than the habit itself. The CoPs approach has already shown efficacy in treatment of tic and Tourette disorder.
The aim of the current open trial was to view whether BFRBs can be validly assessed on a standard tic scale (Tourette Symptom Global Scale; TSGS) and evaluate the efficacy of the CoPs intervention on 64 participants (54 completers) with 1 of 3 subtypes of BFRBs (hair pulling, nail biting, and skin picking) compared to a waitlist control.
Participants were assessed at baseline on an adapted TSGS and after receving 14 weeks of CoPs therapy with six months follow up.
The TSGS was reliably and validly adapted to measure BFRBs. The CoPs intervention was effective for all BRFB subtypes with a large effect size (intention-to-treat g = 1.54; completers g = 2.04), with 74% of patients showing clinically significant improvement. Mood and self-esteem also improved posttreatment. The decrease in symptoms was maintained at the 6-month follow-up, with a further decrease in perfectionism.
BFRBs can be reliably assessed as a tic spectrum disorder rather than as part of the obsessive-compulsive spectrum. The CoPs model may offer a complementary treatment for BFRBs.
专注于身体的重复行为(BFRB),如拔毛、抠皮肤和咬指甲,是重复性、破坏性且无功能的习惯,会造成严重困扰。不同的BFRB构成一个连贯的群体,可作为抽动秽语综合征/抽动谱系或强迫症谱系障碍的一部分进行评估。首选治疗方法是抗抑郁药或行为治疗,两者均已显示出有效性。认知心理生理学(CoPs)模型通过解决发病前的认知行为、情绪和心理生理过程,而非习惯本身,来关注引发习惯的紧张和情绪积累。CoPs方法已在抽动和抽动秽语障碍的治疗中显示出疗效。
本次开放性试验的目的是观察BFRB是否可以在标准抽动量表(抽动秽语症状总体量表;TSGS)上得到有效评估,并评估CoPs干预对64名参与者(54名完成者)的疗效,这些参与者患有三种BFRB亚型(拔毛、咬指甲和抠皮肤)中的一种,并与等待名单对照组进行比较。
参与者在基线时接受适应性TSGS评估,并在接受14周的CoPs治疗后进行6个月的随访。
TSGS经过可靠有效的调整以测量BFRB。CoPs干预对所有BFRB亚型均有效,效应量较大(意向性治疗g = 1.54;完成者g = 2.04),74%的患者显示出临床显著改善。治疗后情绪和自尊也有所改善。症状的减轻在6个月随访时得以维持,完美主义进一步降低。
BFRB可作为抽动谱系障碍而非强迫症谱系的一部分进行可靠评估。CoPs模型可能为BFRB提供一种补充治疗方法。