Suhr Bettina, Six Klaus
Virtual Vehicle Research Center, Inffeldgasse 21/A, A-8010 Graz, Austria.
Granul Matter. 2017;19(4):64. doi: 10.1007/s10035-017-0740-7. Epub 2017 Aug 2.
The prediction quality of discrete element method (DEM) models for railway ballast can be expected to depend on three points: the geometry representation of the single particles, the used contact models and the parametrisation using principal experiments. This works aims at a balanced approach, where none of the points is addressed with excessive depth. In a first step, a simple geometry representation is chosen and the simplified Hertz-Mindlin contact model is used. When experimental data of cyclic compression tests and monotonic direct shear tests are considered, the model can be parametrised to fit either one of the two tests, but not both with the same set of parameters. Similar problems can be found in literature for monotonic and cyclic triaxial tests of railway ballast. In this work, the comparison between experiment and simulation is conducted using the entire data of the test, e.g. shear force over shear path curve from the direct shear test. In addition to a visual comparison of the results also quantitative errors based on the sum of squares are defined. To improve the fit of the DEM model to both types of experiments, an extension on the Hertz-Mindlin contact law is used, which introduces additional physical effects (e.g. breakage of edges or yielding). This model introduces two extra material parameters and is successfully parametrised. Using only one set of parameters, the results of the DEM simulation are in good accordance with both experimental cyclic compression test and monotonic directs shear test.
离散元法(DEM)模型对铁路道砟的预测质量预计取决于三点:单个颗粒的几何表示、所使用的接触模型以及基于主要实验的参数化。本文旨在采用一种平衡的方法,其中对任何一点都不过度深入探讨。第一步,选择一种简单的几何表示,并使用简化的赫兹 - 明德林接触模型。当考虑循环压缩试验和单调直剪试验的实验数据时,该模型可以进行参数化以拟合这两种试验中的任何一种,但不能用同一组参数同时拟合两者。在铁路道砟的单调和循环三轴试验的文献中也能发现类似问题。在这项工作中,使用试验的全部数据进行实验与模拟之间的比较,例如直剪试验中剪切力随剪切路径的曲线。除了对结果进行视觉比较外,还基于平方和定义了定量误差。为了提高DEM模型对两种类型实验的拟合度,对赫兹 - 明德林接触定律进行了扩展,引入了额外的物理效应(例如边缘破碎或屈服)。该模型引入了两个额外的材料参数,并成功进行了参数化。仅使用一组参数,DEM模拟结果就与实验循环压缩试验和单调直剪试验都非常吻合。