Lockeman Kelly S, Appelbaum Nital P, Dow Alan W, Orr Shelly, Huff Tanya A, Hogan Christopher J, Queen Brenda A
Center for Interprofessional Education and Collaborative Care, Virginia Commonwealth University, PO Box 980466, Richmond, VA 23298-0466, United States.
School of Medicine, Virginia Commonwealth University, PO Box 980466, Richmond, VA 23298-0466, United States.
Nurse Educ Today. 2017 Nov;58:32-37. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2017.07.013. Epub 2017 Aug 10.
Interprofessional education is intended to train practitioners to collaboratively address challenges in healthcare delivery, and interprofessional simulation-based education (IPSE) provides realistic, contextual learning experiences in which roles, responsibilities, and professional identity can be learned, developed, and assessed. Reducing negative stereotypes within interprofessional relationships is a prime target for IPSE.
We sought to understand whether perceptions of interprofessional education and provider stereotypes change among nursing and medical students after participating in IPSE. We also sought to determine whether changes differed based on the student's discipline.
This was a quasi-experimental pretest-posttest study.
The study took place at a large mid-Atlantic public university with a comprehensive health science campus.
147 senior Bachelors of Science in Nursing students and 163 fourth-year medical students participated.
Students were grouped into interprofessional teams for a two-week period and participated in three two-hour simulations focused on collaboration around acutely ill patients. At the beginning of the first session, they completed a pretest survey with demographic items and measures of their perceptions of interprofessional clinical education, stereotypes about doctors, and stereotypes about nurses. They completed a posttest with the same measures after the third session.
251 students completed both the pretest and posttest surveys. On all three measures, students showed an overall increase in scores after the IPSE experience. In comparing the change by student discipline, medical students showed little change from pretest to posttest on stereotypes of doctors, while nursing students had a significant increase in positive perceptions about doctors. No differences were noted between disciplines on changes in stereotypes of nurses.
This study demonstrated that a short series of IPSE experiences resulted in improved perceptions of interprofessional practice and changes in stereotypical views of each profession even when the experience was not directly designed to address these issues. Differences observed between nursing and medical students should be explored further.
跨专业教育旨在培养从业者共同应对医疗服务中的挑战,基于模拟的跨专业教育(IPSE)提供了逼真的情境学习体验,在此过程中,角色、职责和职业身份能够得到学习、发展和评估。减少跨专业关系中的负面刻板印象是IPSE的主要目标。
我们试图了解护理专业和医学专业学生在参与IPSE后,对跨专业教育的认知和对医疗服务提供者的刻板印象是否发生变化。我们还试图确定这些变化是否因学生所在学科而异。
这是一项准实验性的前测-后测研究。
该研究在一所位于大西洋中部的大型公立大学进行,该校拥有一个综合性的健康科学园区。
147名护理学理学学士高年级学生和163名四年级医学专业学生参与了研究。
学生们被分成跨专业小组,为期两周,并参加了三次为时两小时的模拟活动,重点是围绕急症患者进行协作。在第一次课程开始时,他们完成了一份前测调查问卷,内容包括人口统计学项目以及他们对跨专业临床教育的认知、对医生的刻板印象和对护士的刻板印象。在第三次课程结束后,他们用相同的测量方法完成了后测。
251名学生完成了前测和后测调查。在所有三项测量中,学生们在IPSE体验后总体得分有所提高。在比较不同学科学生的变化时,医学专业学生对医生的刻板印象从前测到后测变化不大,而护理专业学生对医生的积极认知有显著增加。不同学科在对护士的刻板印象变化方面没有差异。
本研究表明,即使该体验并非直接旨在解决这些问题,短短一系列的IPSE体验也能改善对跨专业实践的认知,并改变对每个专业的刻板看法。护理专业和医学专业学生之间观察到的差异应进一步探讨。