Buckle Abigail, Taylor Celia
Division of Health Sciences, University of Warwick , Coventry, United Kingdom .
Breastfeed Med. 2017 Nov;12(9):528-536. doi: 10.1089/bfm.2017.0057. Epub 2017 Aug 22.
Necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) is a costly gastrointestinal disorder that mainly affects preterm and low-birth-weight infants and can lead to considerable morbidity and mortality. Mother's own milk is protective against NEC but is not always available. In such cases, donor human milk has also been shown to be protective (although to a lesser extent) compared with formula milk, but it is more expensive. This systematic review aimed at evaluating the cost of donor milk, the cost of treating NEC, and the cost-effectiveness of exclusive donor milk versus formula milk feeding to reduce the short-term health and treatment costs of NEC.
We systematically searched five relevant databases to find studies with verifiable costs or charges of donor milk and/or treatment of NEC and any economic evaluations comparing exclusive donor milk with exclusive formula milk feeding. All search results were double screened.
Seven studies with verifiable donor milk costs and 17 with verifiable NEC treatment costs were included. The types of cost or charge included varied considerably across studies, so quantitative synthesis was not attempted. Estimates of the incremental length of stay associated with NEC were ∼18 days for medical NEC and 50 days for surgical NEC. Two studies claimed to report economic evaluations but did not do so in practice.
It is likely that donor milk provides short-term cost savings by reducing the incidence of NEC. Future studies should provide more details on cost components included and a full economic evaluation, including long-term outcomes, should be undertaken.
坏死性小肠结肠炎(NEC)是一种代价高昂的胃肠道疾病,主要影响早产儿和低体重儿,可导致相当高的发病率和死亡率。母亲自己的母乳对NEC有保护作用,但并非总能获得。在这种情况下,与配方奶相比,捐赠人乳也已被证明具有保护作用(尽管程度较小),但成本更高。本系统评价旨在评估捐赠母乳的成本、NEC的治疗成本,以及纯母乳喂养与配方奶喂养相比,减少NEC短期健康和治疗成本的成本效益。
我们系统检索了五个相关数据库,以查找有关捐赠母乳和/或NEC治疗的可核实成本或费用的研究,以及比较纯母乳喂养与纯配方奶喂养的任何经济评估。所有检索结果均进行了双盲筛选。
纳入了七项有可核实捐赠母乳成本的研究和十七项有可核实NEC治疗成本的研究。不同研究中包括的成本或费用类型差异很大,因此未尝试进行定量综合分析。与NEC相关的住院时间增量估计为:医疗性NEC约18天,外科性NEC为50天。两项研究声称报告了经济评估,但实际上并未如此。
捐赠母乳可能通过降低NEC的发病率实现短期成本节约。未来的研究应提供更多关于所包括成本组成部分的详细信息,并应进行全面的经济评估,包括长期结果。