Ma Ting Ting, Zhuang Yan, Gong Hai Ying, Yii Anthony Chauang, Wang Xue Yan, Shi Huan Zhong
Department of Allergy, Beijing Shijitan Hospital, Capital Medical University.
Department of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, Beijing Chao-Yang Hospital, Beijing Institute of Respiratory Medicine, Capital Medical University.
Ther Clin Risk Manag. 2017 Aug 4;13:967-974. doi: 10.2147/TCRM.S138355. eCollection 2017.
The diagnosis of asthma is made on the basis of variable respiratory symptoms and supported by objective evidence of variable airflow limitation. However, spirometry and bronchoprovocation tests may not be routinely available in resource-scarce settings or in the context of large-scale epidemiological studies. There is a gap in knowledge about the predictive value of respiratory symptoms for the diagnosis of pollen-induced asthma.
The aim of this study was to investigate the predictive value of self-reported respiratory symptoms for diagnosing pollen-induced asthma.
We recruited 1,161 patients with respiratory symptoms who presented to the respiratory medicine outpatient clinic of two central hospitals in Inner Mongolia during the pollen season of July-September 2015. All patients were interviewed by a respiratory physician and completed a questionnaire survey, lung function tests and skin prick tests for common inhaled allergens.
A total of 392 patients (33.8%) were diagnosed with asthma and 292 (25.2%, 160 adults, 132 children) with pollen-induced asthma. Respiratory symptoms of cough, wheezing, dyspnea, chest pain and nocturnal awakenings due to breathlessness were all associated with increased odds of being diagnosed with pollen-induced asthma, with cough being the most common symptom in both adults and children, giving a sensitivity of 90.6% in adults and 88.6% in children. Wheezing was the most specific symptom (78% and 89.5% in adults and children, respectively) compared to other symptoms. Overall, the positive predictive value of respiratory symptoms was poor for diagnosing pollen-induced asthma, with the exception of wheezing in children which had a high positive predictive value of 72.7%.
Cough was the predominant symptom in adults and children with pollen-induced asthma. Wheezing was a reliable predictor of pollen-induced asthma in children. In adults, respiratory symptoms were not sufficiently reliable for diagnosing pollen-induced asthma.
哮喘的诊断基于多变的呼吸道症状,并由气流受限多变的客观证据支持。然而,在资源匮乏地区或大规模流行病学研究中,肺功能测定和支气管激发试验可能无法常规开展。关于呼吸道症状对花粉诱发哮喘诊断的预测价值,目前存在知识空白。
本研究旨在调查自我报告的呼吸道症状对诊断花粉诱发哮喘的预测价值。
我们招募了1161例有呼吸道症状的患者,这些患者于2015年7月至9月花粉季节期间前往内蒙古两家中心医院的呼吸内科门诊就诊。所有患者均由呼吸科医生进行访谈,并完成问卷调查、肺功能测试以及常见吸入性变应原的皮肤点刺试验。
共有392例患者(33.8%)被诊断为哮喘,292例(25.2%,其中成人160例,儿童132例)被诊断为花粉诱发哮喘。咳嗽、喘息、呼吸困难、胸痛以及因气促导致的夜间觉醒等呼吸道症状均与被诊断为花粉诱发哮喘的几率增加相关,咳嗽是成人和儿童中最常见的症状,在成人中的敏感性为90.6%,在儿童中为88.6%。与其他症状相比,喘息是最具特异性的症状(成人和儿童中分别为78%和89.5%)。总体而言,呼吸道症状对诊断花粉诱发哮喘的阳性预测价值较差,不过儿童喘息具有较高的阳性预测价值,为72.7%。
咳嗽是花粉诱发哮喘成人和儿童中的主要症状。喘息是儿童花粉诱发哮喘的可靠预测指标。在成人中,呼吸道症状对诊断花粉诱发哮喘的可靠性不足。