Gele Abdi A, Ahmed Mohamed Yusuf, Kour Prabhjot, Moallim Sadiyo Ali, Salad Abdulwahab Moallim, Kumar Bernadette
Institute of Nursing and Health Promotion, Department of Health, Oslo and Akershus University College of Applied Science.
Department for Research, Norwegian Centre for Minority Health Research, Oslo, Norway.
Risk Manag Healthc Policy. 2017 Aug 1;10:127-135. doi: 10.2147/RMHP.S136170. eCollection 2017.
In 2005, the World Health Conference called for all nations to move toward universal health coverage, which is defined as "access to adequate health care for all at an affordable price". Despite this, an estimated 90% of Somalia's largely impoverished population use private health care. Therefore, considering that the private health care system is the dominant health care system in Mogadishu, Somalia, exploring the accessibility to, as well as people's trust in, the private sector is essential to help contribute an equitable and affordable health care system in the country.
A qualitative study using unstructured interviews was conducted in Mogadishu from August to November of 2016. A purposive sampling approach was used to recruit 23 participants, including seven medical doctors who own private health centers, eight patients, five medical students and three senior officials who work for the Ministry of Health. Data were analyzed using a thematic analysis.
Our findings show that the private health care system in Mogadishu is not only unregulated but also expensive, with the cost of health care often unaffordable for the majority of the country's citizens. There is evidence of prescription of inappropriate treatment, tendency to conduct unnecessary laboratory tests, excessive use of higher diagnostic technologies and overcharging - including the widespread practice of further appointments for follow-up - which inflates the costs. The study also found poor patient-provider relationship and widespread distrust of the private health care system.
The study findings underline the need for the Somali government to develop regulatory mechanisms and guidelines with the potential to guide the private health care sector to provide equitable and affordable health care to people in Mogadishu. The doctor-patient relationship has been - and remains - a keystone of care; thus, there is an urgent need for guidelines for private health care providers to treat their patients with dignity and respect. The education system, particularly the syllabus used by medical faculties, should be reviewed and improved to provide medical students with necessary knowledge, skills and attitudes to maintain patient dignity and rights.
2005年,世界卫生大会呼吁所有国家朝着全民健康覆盖的目标迈进,全民健康覆盖的定义是“让所有人都能以可承受的价格获得充足的医疗保健服务”。尽管如此,据估计,索马里大部分贫困人口中有90%使用私立医疗保健服务。因此,鉴于私立医疗保健系统是索马里摩加迪沙的主要医疗保健系统,探索私立部门的可及性以及人们对其的信任度,对于在该国建立一个公平且可负担得起的医疗保健系统至关重要。
2016年8月至11月在摩加迪沙进行了一项采用非结构化访谈的定性研究。采用目的抽样法招募了23名参与者,包括7名拥有私立医疗中心的医生、8名患者、5名医科学生和3名卫生部高级官员。使用主题分析法对数据进行了分析。
我们的研究结果表明,摩加迪沙的私立医疗保健系统不仅缺乏监管且费用高昂,该国大多数公民往往难以负担医疗保健费用。有证据表明存在不当治疗处方、进行不必要实验室检查的倾向、过度使用更高诊断技术以及收费过高的情况——包括普遍存在的后续复诊预约收费——这推高了成本。该研究还发现医患关系不佳以及人们对私立医疗保健系统普遍不信任。
研究结果强调索马里政府需要制定监管机制和指导方针,以引导私立医疗保健部门为摩加迪沙民众提供公平且可负担得起的医疗保健服务。医患关系一直是且仍然是医疗护理的基石;因此,迫切需要为私立医疗保健提供者制定指导方针,使其以尊严和尊重对待患者。应审查并改进教育系统,特别是医学院使用的教学大纲,以便为医科学生提供维护患者尊严和权利所需的知识、技能和态度。