Medical Education Secretary, Medicine School, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Facultad de Medicina, Edificio B, 3er piso, Zip code, 04510, Coyoacán, Mexico.
Medical Internship Department, Clinical Teaching Secretary, Medicine School, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City, Mexico.
BMC Med Educ. 2017 Aug 25;17(1):143. doi: 10.1186/s12909-017-0980-6.
Competency-based education has been considered the most important pedagogical trend in Medicine in the last two decades. In clinical contexts, competencies are implemented through Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) which are observable and measurable. The aim of this paper is to describe the methodology used in the design of educational tools to assess students´ competencies in clinical practice during their undergraduate internship (UI). In this paper, we present the construction of specific APROCs (Actividades Profesionales Confiables) in Surgery (S), Gynecology and Obstetrics (GO) and Family Medicine (FM) rotations with three levels of performance.
The study considered a mixed method exploratory type design, a qualitative phase followed by a quantitative validation exercise. In the first stage data was obtained from three rotations (FM, GO and S) through focus groups about real and expected activities of medical interns. Triangulation with other sources was made to construct benchmarks. In the second stage, narrative descriptions with the three levels were validated by professors who teach the different subjects using the Delphi technique.
The results may be described both curricular and methodological wise. From the curricular point of view, APROCs were identified in three UI rotations within clinical contexts in Mexico City, benchmarks were developed by levels and validated by experts' consensus. In regard to methodological issues, this research contributed to the development of a strategy, following six steps, to build APROCs using mixed methods.
Developing benchmarks provides a regular and standardized language that helps to evaluate student's performance and define educational strategies efficiently and accurately. The university academic program was aligned with APROCs in clinical contexts to assure the acquisition of competencies by students.
在过去二十年中,以能力为基础的教育被认为是医学领域最重要的教学趋势。在临床环境中,能力是通过可观察和可衡量的可委托专业活动(EPAs)来实施的。本文旨在描述用于设计评估学生在本科实习期间(UI)临床实践能力的教育工具的方法。在本文中,我们介绍了在外科(S)、妇科和产科(GO)以及家庭医学(FM)实习轮转中构建具有三个绩效水平的特定 APROCs(可靠的专业活动)的方法。
该研究采用混合方法探索性设计,包括定性阶段和定量验证练习。在第一阶段,通过关于医学实习生实际和预期活动的焦点小组,从三个轮转(FM、GO 和 S)中获取数据。通过与其他来源的三角测量来构建基准。在第二阶段,使用 Delphi 技术,教授对具有三个层次的叙述描述进行验证。
结果可以从课程和方法两个方面进行描述。从课程角度来看,在墨西哥城的三个 UI 轮转中确定了 APROCs,在临床背景下,根据水平制定了基准,并通过专家共识进行了验证。在方法问题方面,这项研究为使用混合方法构建 APROCs 提供了一个策略,共六个步骤。
开发基准为评估学生的表现和有效地、准确地制定教育策略提供了一个常规和标准化的语言。大学学术计划与临床背景下的 APROCs 保持一致,以确保学生获得能力。