Bissett Patrick G, Grant Lauren D, Weissman Daniel H
Department of Psychology, Stanford University, United States.
Department of Psychology, University of Michigan, United States.
Acta Psychol (Amst). 2017 Oct;180:40-51. doi: 10.1016/j.actpsy.2017.08.009. Epub 2017 Aug 23.
Resisting distraction and response inhibition are crucial aspects of cognitive control. Interestingly, each of these abilities transiently improves just after it is utilized. Competing views differ, however, as to whether utilizing either of these abilities (e.g., resisting distraction) enhances future performance involving the other ability (e.g., response inhibition). To distinguish between these views, we combined a Stroop-like task that requires resisting distraction with a restraint variant of the stop-signal task that requires response inhibition. We observed similar sequential-trial effects (i.e., performance enhancements) following trials in which participants (a) resisted distraction (i.e., incongruent go trials) and (b) inhibited a response (i.e., congruent stop trials). First, the congruency effect in go trials, which indexes overall distractibility, was smaller after both incongruent go trials and congruent stop trials than it was after congruent go trials. Second, stop failures were less frequent after both incongruent go trials and congruent stop trials than after congruent go trials. A control experiment ruled out the possibility that perceptual conflict or surprise engendered by occasional stop signals triggers sequential-trial effects independent of stopping. Thus, our findings support a novel, integrated view in which resisting distraction and response inhibition trigger similar sequential enhancements of future performance.
抵制干扰和反应抑制是认知控制的关键方面。有趣的是,这些能力中的每一种在被运用之后都会短暂地得到提升。然而,对于运用这些能力中的任何一种(例如抵制干扰)是否会提高涉及另一种能力(例如反应抑制)的未来表现,存在不同的观点。为了区分这些观点,我们将一项需要抵制干扰的类斯特鲁普任务与一项需要反应抑制的停止信号任务的抑制变体相结合。我们观察到,在参与者(a)抵制干扰(即不一致的执行试验)和(b)抑制反应(即一致的停止试验)的试验之后,出现了类似的顺序试验效应(即表现提升)。首先,执行试验中的一致性效应(它指示整体的可干扰性)在不一致的执行试验和一致的停止试验之后都比在一致的执行试验之后小。其次,在不一致的执行试验和一致的停止试验之后,停止失败的情况都比在一致的执行试验之后更少。一项对照实验排除了偶尔的停止信号所引发的感知冲突或意外会触发独立于停止的顺序试验效应的可能性。因此,我们的研究结果支持了一种新颖的综合观点,即抵制干扰和反应抑制会触发未来表现的类似顺序增强。