Research Planning, Inc. (RPI), 247 E. 7th Avenue, Suite 200, Tallahassee, FL 32303, USA.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 61389 Highway 434, Lacombe, LA 70445, USA.
Sci Total Environ. 2018 Jan 15;612:231-237. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2017.08.221. Epub 2017 Sep 1.
In-situ burning of oiled marshes is a cleanup method that can be more effective and less damaging than intrusive manual and mechanical methods. In-situ burning of oil spills has been examined for several coastal marsh types; however, few published data are available for Phragmites australis marshes. Following an estimated 4200gallon crude oil spill and in-situ burn in a Phragmites tidal freshwater marsh at Delta National Wildlife Refuge (Mississippi River Delta, Louisiana), we examined vegetation impacts and recovery across 3years. Oil concentrations in marsh soils were initially elevated in the oiled-and-burned sites, but were below background levels within three months. Oiling and burning drastically affected the marsh vegetation; the formerly dominant Phragmites, a non-native variety in our study sites, had not fully recovered by the end of our study. However, overall vegetation recovery was rapid and local habitat quality in terms of native plants, particularly Sagittaria species, and wildlife value was enhanced by burning. In-situ burning appears to be a viable response option to consider for future spills in marshes with similar plant species composition, hydrogeomorphic settings, and oiling conditions. In addition, likely Phragmites stress from high water levels and/or non-native scale insect damage was also observed during our study and has recently been reported as causing widespread declines or loss of Phragmites stands in the Delta region. It remains an open question if these stressors could lead to a shift to more native vegetation, similar to what we observed following the oil spill and burn. Increased dominance by native plants may be desirable as local patches, but widespread loss of Phragmites, even if replaced by native species, could further acerbate coastal erosion and wetland loss, a major concern in the region.
原位燃烧是一种清理方法,与侵入性的人工和机械方法相比,它可能更有效,破坏性更小。已经对几种沿海沼泽类型进行了溢油原位燃烧研究;然而,可供查阅的用于芦苇沼泽的资料很少。在密西西比河三角洲的三角洲国家野生动物保护区(Delta National Wildlife Refuge)发生了估计有 4200 加仑原油泄漏和原位燃烧之后,我们在 3 年内对植被影响和恢复情况进行了调查。油污染和燃烧后的沼泽土壤中的石油浓度最初升高,但在三个月内降至背景水平以下。石油污染和燃烧对沼泽植被产生了巨大影响;在我们的研究地点,曾经占主导地位的、非本地品种的芦苇尚未完全恢复。然而,总体而言,植被恢复迅速,本地栖息地质量(包括本地植物,特别是慈姑属植物)和野生动物价值因燃烧而得到提高。原位燃烧似乎是一种可行的应对选择,可用于未来在具有类似植物物种组成、水文地貌和石油污染条件的沼泽中发生的溢油事件。此外,在我们的研究期间还观察到由于水位高和/或非本地介壳虫损害导致的芦苇可能出现的压力,最近有报道称,这导致三角洲地区的芦苇大量减少或消失。这些压力因素是否会导致向更具本地植被的转变,类似于我们在溢油和燃烧后观察到的情况,这仍然是一个悬而未决的问题。增加本地植物的优势可能是局部斑块的理想选择,但即使被本地物种取代,芦苇的广泛消失也可能进一步加剧沿海侵蚀和湿地损失,这是该地区的一个主要关注点。