Espinoza Vega M L, Martín Rivada A, Rico Espiñeira C, De Lucio Rodríguez M, Guillén Redondo P, Luis Huertas A L, Souto Romero H, Espinosa Góngora R, Ollero Fresno J C
Servicio de Cirugía Pediátrica. Hospital Infantil Universitario Niño Jesús. Madrid.
Servicio de Pediatría. Hospital Infantil Universitario Niño Jesús. Madrid.
Cir Pediatr. 2017 Apr 20;30(2):95-99.
To estimate the recurrence rate of intussusception after successful enema reduction and to analyze the costs of hospital admission with the current management of this pathology.
A retrospective study over 5 years of 97 patients with confirmed diagnosis of intussusception was undertaken. Medical records were evaluated for patient demographic, clinical and radiological data. Patients with enema-reduced intussusception were selected and data respecting to timing and outcome of recurrences, and length of stay were analyzed. Recurrence was defined as a new episode of intussusception within 72 hours of the initial presentation. Costs were calculated using hospital-specific data.
During the study period there were 81/97 children with successful enema reduction. Mean length of stay was 35 hours in the conservative treatment group. There were 8 episodes of recurrence, 5 of them within the first 24 hours (6.17%), for an overall recurrence rate of 9.88%. 7 children were treated by repeated enema and only one patient needed surgery for persistent illness. Assuming the overall recurrence rate of 9.88%, it would require hospitalizing 16 patients to identify a single recurrence with a cost of 1,723.75 € per patient.
Given the low recurrence rate for enema-reduced intussusception and the possibility of repeated enema for their treatment in most of recurrences, we strongly advocated for the outpatient management as a safe and cost-effective alternative.
评估灌肠复位成功后肠套叠的复发率,并分析当前对此病症治疗方法下的住院费用。
对97例确诊为肠套叠的患者进行了为期5年的回顾性研究。对病历中的患者人口统计学、临床和放射学数据进行了评估。选取经灌肠复位的肠套叠患者,分析复发的时间和结果以及住院时间等数据。复发定义为在初次出现症状后72小时内出现新的肠套叠发作。费用根据医院的具体数据进行计算。
在研究期间,97例患儿中有81例灌肠复位成功。保守治疗组的平均住院时间为35小时。有8例复发,其中5例在最初24小时内(6.17%),总体复发率为9.88%。7名儿童接受了重复灌肠治疗,只有1名患者因病情持续需要手术。假设总体复发率为9.88%,则需要住院16名患者才能发现1例复发,每名患者的费用为1,723.75欧元。
鉴于灌肠复位后肠套叠的复发率较低,且大多数复发情况可通过重复灌肠治疗,我们强烈主张将门诊管理作为一种安全且经济有效的替代方案。