Ali Taqdir, Hussain Maqbool, Ali Khan Wajahat, Afzal Muhammad, Hussain Jamil, Ali Rahman, Hassan Waseem, Jamshed Arif, Kang Byeong Ho, Lee Sungyoung
Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Kyung Hee University, Seocheon-dong, Giheung-gu, Yongin-si 446-701, Gyeonggi-do, Republic of Korea.
Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Kyung Hee University, Seocheon-dong, Giheung-gu, Yongin-si 446-701, Gyeonggi-do, Republic of Korea; College of Electronics and Information Engineering, Sejong University, Seoul, South Korea.
Comput Methods Programs Biomed. 2017 Oct;150:41-72. doi: 10.1016/j.cmpb.2017.07.010. Epub 2017 Jul 22.
Technologically integrated healthcare environments can be realized if physicians are encouraged to use smart systems for the creation and sharing of knowledge used in clinical decision support systems (CDSS). While CDSSs are heading toward smart environments, they lack support for abstraction of technology-oriented knowledge from physicians. Therefore, abstraction in the form of a user-friendly and flexible authoring environment is required in order for physicians to create shareable and interoperable knowledge for CDSS workflows. Our proposed system provides a user-friendly authoring environment to create Arden Syntax MLM (Medical Logic Module) as shareable knowledge rules for intelligent decision-making by CDSS.
Existing systems are not physician friendly and lack interoperability and shareability of knowledge. In this paper, we proposed Intelligent-Knowledge Authoring Tool (I-KAT), a knowledge authoring environment that overcomes the above mentioned limitations. Shareability is achieved by creating a knowledge base from MLMs using Arden Syntax. Interoperability is enhanced using standard data models and terminologies. However, creation of shareable and interoperable knowledge using Arden Syntax without abstraction increases complexity, which ultimately makes it difficult for physicians to use the authoring environment. Therefore, physician friendliness is provided by abstraction at the application layer to reduce complexity. This abstraction is regulated by mappings created between legacy system concepts, which are modeled as domain clinical model (DCM) and decision support standards such as virtual medical record (vMR) and Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine - Clinical Terms (SNOMED CT). We represent these mappings with a semantic reconciliation model (SRM).
The objective of the study is the creation of shareable and interoperable knowledge using a user-friendly and flexible I-KAT. Therefore we evaluated our system using completeness and user satisfaction criteria, which we assessed through the system- and user-centric evaluation processes. For system-centric evaluation, we compared the implementation of clinical information modelling system requirements in our proposed system and in existing systems. The results suggested that 82.05% of the requirements were fully supported, 7.69% were partially supported, and 10.25% were not supported by our system. In the existing systems, 35.89% of requirements were fully supported, 28.20% were partially supported, and 35.89% were not supported. For user-centric evaluation, the assessment criterion was 'ease of use'. Our proposed system showed 15 times better results with respect to MLM creation time than the existing systems. Moreover, on average, the participants made only one error in MLM creation using our proposed system, but 13 errors per MLM using the existing systems.
We provide a user-friendly authoring environment for creation of shareable and interoperable knowledge for CDSS to overcome knowledge acquisition complexity. The authoring environment uses state-of-the-art decision support-related clinical standards with increased ease of use.
如果鼓励医生使用智能系统来创建和共享临床决策支持系统(CDSS)中使用的知识,那么技术集成的医疗环境就可以实现。虽然CDSS正朝着智能环境发展,但它们缺乏对从医生那里提取面向技术的知识的支持。因此,需要一个用户友好且灵活的创作环境形式的抽象,以便医生为CDSS工作流程创建可共享和可互操作的知识。我们提出的系统提供了一个用户友好的创作环境,以创建Arden语法MLM(医学逻辑模块)作为CDSS进行智能决策的可共享知识规则。
现有系统对医生不友好,并且缺乏知识的互操作性和可共享性。在本文中,我们提出了智能知识创作工具(I-KAT),这是一个克服上述限制的知识创作环境。通过使用Arden语法从MLM创建知识库来实现可共享性。使用标准数据模型和术语来增强互操作性。然而,在没有抽象的情况下使用Arden语法创建可共享和可互操作的知识会增加复杂性,这最终使医生难以使用创作环境。因此,通过在应用层进行抽象以降低复杂性来提供医生友好性。这种抽象由在遗留系统概念之间创建的映射来调节,这些概念被建模为领域临床模型(DCM)以及诸如虚拟病历(vMR)和医学系统命名法 - 临床术语(SNOMED CT)等决策支持标准。我们用语义协调模型(SRM)来表示这些映射。
本研究的目标是使用用户友好且灵活的I-KAT创建可共享和可互操作的知识。因此,我们使用完整性和用户满意度标准对我们的系统进行了评估,我们通过以系统为中心和以用户为中心的评估过程来评估这些标准。对于以系统为中心的评估,我们比较了我们提出的系统和现有系统中临床信息建模系统要求的实现情况。结果表明,我们的系统完全支持82.05%的要求,部分支持7.69%,不支持10.25%。在现有系统中,35.89%的要求得到完全支持,28.20%得到部分支持,35.89%不支持。对于以用户为中心的评估,评估标准是“易用性”。我们提出的系统在MLM创建时间方面比现有系统表现出好15倍的结果。此外,平均而言,参与者使用我们提出的系统在创建MLM时仅犯一个错误,但使用现有系统时每个MLM犯13个错误。
我们提供了一个用户友好的创作环境,用于为CDSS创建可共享和可互操作的知识,以克服知识获取的复杂性。该创作环境使用了与决策支持相关的最新临床标准,并且易用性有所提高。