Gluck Samuel, Chapple Lee-Anne S, Chapman Marianne J, Iwashyna Theodore J, Deane Adam M
Discipline of Acute Care Medicine, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA, Australia.
Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Mich, United States.
Crit Care Resusc. 2017 Sep;19(3):197-204.
Wearable devices using new technology may be a cost-effective method to assess functional outcomes in survivors of critical illness. Our primary objective was to review the extent to which wearable devices such as smartphones, pedometers, accelerometers and global positioning systems have been used to evaluate outcomes in survivors of an intensive care unit admission.
We included studies of patients surviving an ICU admission and which measured outcomes using wearable devices. We performed a scoping review of studies found by searching the CINAHL, Embase, MEDLINE and PubMed databases.
The seven studies we identified were published in or after 2012 and were predominantly descriptive (n = 6) with one randomised controlled trial. All studies described outcomes in cohorts of relatively few participants (range, 11-51 participants). Duration to follow-up was mostly short, at a median time of 3 months after ICU discharge (range, in-hospital to 27 years). All studies used accelerometers to monitor patient movement: physical activity (n = 5), sleep quality (n = 1), and infant movement (n = 1). The accelerometers were bi-axial (n = 3), uni-axial (n = 2) combined uni-axial (n = 1) and tri-axial (n = 1). Common outcomes evaluated were the number of participants walking for < 30 min/day, mean daily step count and walking speed.
Wearable devices have infrequently been used to measure physical activity in survivors of critical illness and all identified studies were published recently, which suggests that the use of wearable devices for research may be increasing. To date, only accelerometry has been reported, and the wide variation in methodologies used and the outcomes measured limits synthesis of these data.
使用新技术的可穿戴设备可能是评估危重症幸存者功能结局的一种经济有效的方法。我们的主要目的是回顾智能手机、计步器、加速度计和全球定位系统等可穿戴设备在评估重症监护病房(ICU)入院幸存者结局方面的应用程度。
我们纳入了对ICU入院幸存者进行的研究,这些研究使用可穿戴设备测量结局。我们对通过检索CINAHL、Embase、MEDLINE和PubMed数据库找到的研究进行了范围综述。
我们确定的7项研究发表于2012年或之后,主要是描述性研究(n = 6),有1项随机对照试验。所有研究描述的参与者队列规模相对较小(范围为11 - 51名参与者)。随访时间大多较短,中位时间为ICU出院后3个月(范围为住院期间至27年)。所有研究都使用加速度计监测患者活动:身体活动(n = 5)、睡眠质量(n = 1)和婴儿活动(n = 1)。加速度计为双轴(n = 3)、单轴(n = 2)、组合单轴(n = 1)和三轴(n = 1)。评估的常见结局包括每天步行< 30分钟的参与者数量、平均每日步数和步行速度。
可穿戴设备很少用于测量危重症幸存者的身体活动,所有已确定的研究均为近期发表,这表明可穿戴设备在研究中的应用可能正在增加。迄今为止,仅报告了加速度测量法,并且所使用的方法和测量的结局差异很大,限制了这些数据的综合分析。