Iannotti Joseph P, Jun Bong-Jae, Patterson Thomas E, Ricchetti Eric T
1Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2017 Sep 6;99(17):1460-1468. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.16.00869.
Osteoarthritis of the glenohumeral joint has typical patterns of deformity as described by Walch et al. However, more severe glenoid pathology may be difficult to classify. The purpose of this study was to use 3-dimensional computed tomography (3-D CT) imaging analysis to define common pathologic subtypes that can be differentiated from the current Walch classification.
We performed quantitative measurements of premorbid and pathologic anatomy using preoperative 3-D CT scans from 155 cases of advanced glenohumeral osteoarthritis that underwent anatomic or reverse total shoulder arthroplasty. We defined premorbid glenohumeral anatomy on the basis of previously validated methods using 3-D glenoid vault and humeral best-fit circle models including the premorbid glenoid version, joint-line medialization, and humeral-glenoid alignment (HGA). We determined the anatomic features that differentiate new glenoid morphologic subtypes from the existing Walch classification both qualitatively and quantitatively.
We defined 2 new glenoid subtypes (B3 and C2) for which the glenoid pathology and humeral alignment were not defined in the original Walch classification. The B3 glenoid has high pathologic retroversion, normal premorbid version, and acquired central and posterior bone loss that, on average, is greater than that of the B2 glenoid. The C2 glenoid is dysplastic with high pathologic retroversion, high premorbid version, and acquired posterior bone loss, giving it the appearance of a biconcave glenoid with posterior translation of the humeral head. This C2 glenoid can be confused with the B2 glenoid.
The B3 and C2 patterns have qualitative and quantitative differences that may result in different clinical outcomes than classic B2 or C types; therefore, our findings suggest that these new subtypes should be included in a new or modified classification system.
如Walch等人所述,盂肱关节骨关节炎具有典型的畸形模式。然而,更严重的肩胛盂病理改变可能难以分类。本研究的目的是使用三维计算机断层扫描(3-D CT)成像分析来定义可与当前Walch分类相区分的常见病理亚型。
我们使用术前3-D CT扫描对155例接受解剖型或反向全肩关节置换术的晚期盂肱关节骨关节炎病例的病前和病理解剖结构进行了定量测量。我们基于先前验证的方法,使用三维肩胛盂穹顶和肱骨最佳拟合圆模型(包括病前肩胛盂版本、关节线内移和肱盂对线(HGA))来定义病前盂肱关节解剖结构。我们定性和定量地确定了将新的肩胛盂形态学亚型与现有Walch分类区分开来的解剖学特征。
我们定义了2种新的肩胛盂亚型(B3和C2),其肩胛盂病理改变和肱骨对线在原始Walch分类中未作定义。B3型肩胛盂具有高度病理性后倾、正常病前版本以及获得性中央和后部骨质流失,平均而言,其骨质流失程度大于B2型肩胛盂。C2型肩胛盂发育不良,具有高度病理性后倾、高度病前版本以及获得性后部骨质流失,使其呈现出肱骨头后移的双凹形肩胛盂外观。这种C2型肩胛盂可能会与B2型肩胛盂混淆。
B3和C2模式在定性和定量方面存在差异,可能导致与经典的B2或C型不同的临床结果;因此,我们的研究结果表明,这些新亚型应纳入新的或修订的分类系统。