Noh Woon Jae, Park Tae Jung, Kim Joo Yeon, Kwon Jae Hwan
*Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Maryknoll Medical Center †Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Kosin University Gospel Hospital, Busan, Korea.
J Craniofac Surg. 2017 Oct;28(7):1824-1827. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0000000000003871.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the usefulness of C-arm fluoroscan with a balloon catheter in patients undergoing closed reduction of zygomatic arch fractures.
All patients who had zygomatic arch reduction surgery between 2006 and 2015 were identified and classified into 2 groups. Group A included those patients who underwent closed reduction of zygomatic arch fractures. Group B included those who underwent zygomatic arch reduction surgery with a C-arm fluoroscan and supporting balloon. A balloon catheter was used to stabilize the zygomatic bone after reduction. Results were scored from 1 (poor) to 3 (good) to assess surgical outcomes based on 3 criteria: alignment of the zygomatic arch on a postoperative computed tomography scan, facial asymmetry in photography, and the patient's subjective satisfaction.
The authors enrolled 32 patients with zygomatic arch fractures. 18 patients underwent closed reduction for zygomatic arch fractures (group A), while 14 patients underwent closed reduction with C-arm fluoroscan and balloon support (group B). The average score for group A was 2.00 for alignment, 2.56 for facial asymmetry, and 2.67 for subjective satisfaction compared with 2.64 for alignment, 2.86 for facial asymmetry, and 2.79 for subjective satisfaction in group B. There were statistically significant differences in the alignment and facial asymmetry scores between the 2 groups.
The authors suggest that C-arm fluoroscan with balloon support is a useful modality for reduction of zygomatic arch fractures that provides better surgical outcomes than conventional closed reduction surgery.
本研究旨在评估在颧弓骨折闭合复位患者中使用带球囊导管的C型臂荧光透视扫描的有效性。
确定并分类2006年至2015年间所有接受颧弓复位手术的患者为两组。A组包括接受颧弓骨折闭合复位的患者。B组包括接受C型臂荧光透视扫描及配套球囊辅助的颧弓复位手术的患者。复位后使用球囊导管稳定颧骨。根据术后计算机断层扫描上颧弓的对线情况、摄影中的面部不对称情况以及患者的主观满意度这三项标准,将结果从1分(差)至3分(好)进行评分,以评估手术效果。
作者纳入了32例颧弓骨折患者。18例患者接受了颧弓骨折闭合复位(A组),而14例患者接受了C型臂荧光透视扫描及球囊辅助的闭合复位(B组)。A组的对线平均评分为2.00分,面部不对称评分为2.56分,主观满意度评分为2.67分;相比之下,B组的对线评分为2.64分,面部不对称评分为2.86分,主观满意度评分为2.79分。两组之间的对线和面部不对称评分存在统计学显著差异。
作者认为,带球囊辅助的C型臂荧光透视扫描是一种用于颧弓骨折复位的有效方式,其手术效果优于传统的闭合复位手术。