Au Ivan P H, Fan Pak Che Patricia, Lee Wang Yiu, Leong Man Wai, Tang Oi Yin, An Winko W, Cheung Roy T
a Department of Rehabilitation Sciences, Faculty of Health and Social Sciences , The Hong Kong Polytechnic University , Hung Hom, Hong Kong , China.
b Byrne, Hickman & Partners Physiotherapy Clinic , Hong Kong , China.
Physiother Theory Pract. 2017 Dec;33(12):914-919. doi: 10.1080/09593985.2017.1359871. Epub 2017 Sep 12.
To determine the true and immediate effect of applying Kinesio tape (KT) on the pain intensity, pain-free grip strength, maximal grip strength, and electromyographic activity with facilitatory KT, inhibitory KT, sham KT, and untaped condition in patients with lateral epicondylitis (LE) who were ignorant about KT.
Deceptive crossover trial.
Thirty-three patients with unilateral chronic LE who were ignorant about KT, 30 of them were successfully deceived in this study.
Patients were randomly allocated into different sequences of four taping conditions: facilitatory KT, inhibitory KT, sham KT, and untaped condition.
Pain intensity, pain-free grip strength, maximal grip strength, and electromyographic activity of wrist extensor muscles were assessed immediately after each tape application.
No significant differences in the pain intensity (p = 0.321, η = 0.04); pain-free grip strength (p = 0.312, η = 0.04); maximal grip strength (p = 0.499, η = 0.03); and electromyographic activity (maximal grip: p = 0.774, η = 0.01; and pain-free grip: p = 0.618, η = 0.02) were recorded among various taping conditions.
Neither facilitatory nor inhibitory effects were observed between different application techniques of KT in patients with LE. Hence, alternative intervention should be used to manage LE.
确定在对肌内效贴布(KT)一无所知的外侧上髁炎(LE)患者中,使用促进型KT、抑制型KT、假KT以及不贴KT时,KT对疼痛强度、无痛握力、最大握力和肌电图活动的真实即时效果。
欺骗性交叉试验。
33名单侧慢性LE患者,他们对KT一无所知,其中30人在本研究中被成功欺骗。
患者被随机分配到四种贴扎条件的不同顺序中:促进型KT、抑制型KT、假KT和不贴KT。
每次贴扎后立即评估疼痛强度、无痛握力、最大握力以及腕伸肌的肌电图活动。
在不同贴扎条件下,疼痛强度(p = 0.321,η = 0.04)、无痛握力(p = 0.312,η = 0.04)、最大握力(p = 0.499,η = 0.03)以及肌电图活动(最大握力时:p = 0.774,η = 0.01;无痛握力时:p = 0.618,η = 0.02)均未观察到显著差异。
在LE患者中,不同的KT应用技术之间未观察到促进或抑制作用。因此,应采用其他干预措施来治疗LE。