Field Tiffany
Touch Research Institute, University of Miami/Miller School of Medicine, United States; Fielding Graduate University, United States.
Infant Behav Dev. 2017 Nov;49:141-150. doi: 10.1016/j.infbeh.2017.09.002. Epub 2017 Sep 9.
This narrative review is based on a literature search of PubMed and PsycINFO for research on preterm newborn pain published during the last ten years. The high prevalence of painful procedures being performed with preterm newborns without analgesia (79%), with a median of 75 painful procedures being received during hospitalization and as many as 51 painful procedures per day highlights the importance of this problem. This review covers the pain assessments that have been developed, the short-term effects of the painful procedures, the longer-term developmental outcomes and the pharmacological and alternative therapies that have been researched. The most immediate effects reported for repeated painful procedures include increased heart rate, oxidative stress and cortisol as well as decreased vagal activity. Lower body weight and head circumference have been noted at 32 weeks gestation. Blunted cortisol reactivity to stressors has been reported for three-month-olds and thinner gray matter in 21 of 66 cerebral regions and motor and cognitive developmental delays have been noted as early as eight months. Longer-term outcomes have been reported at school age including less cortical thickness, lower vagal activity, delayed visual- perceptual development, lower IQs and internalizing behavior. Pharmacological interventions and their side effects and non-pharmacological therapies are also reviewed including sucrose, milk and nonnutritive sucking which have been effective but thought to negatively affect breast-feeding. Full-body interventions have included tucking, swaddling, kangaroo care and massage therapy. Although these have been effective for alleviating immediate pain during invasive procedures, research is lacking on the routine use of these therapies for reducing long-term pain effects. Further, additional randomized controlled replication studies are needed.
本叙述性综述基于对PubMed和PsycINFO的文献检索,以查找过去十年中发表的关于早产新生儿疼痛的研究。在未实施镇痛的情况下对早产新生儿进行痛苦操作的比例很高(79%),住院期间接受痛苦操作的中位数为75次,每天多达51次,这凸显了该问题的重要性。本综述涵盖了已开发的疼痛评估方法、痛苦操作的短期影响、长期发育结果以及已研究的药物和替代疗法。重复痛苦操作报告的最直接影响包括心率加快、氧化应激和皮质醇升高以及迷走神经活动降低。在妊娠32周时发现体重和头围较低。据报道,三个月大的婴儿对压力源的皮质醇反应迟钝,66个脑区中有21个脑区的灰质变薄,早在八个月时就注意到运动和认知发育延迟。在学龄期报告了长期结果,包括皮质厚度变薄、迷走神经活动降低、视觉感知发育延迟、智商较低和内化行为。还综述了药物干预及其副作用以及非药物疗法,包括蔗糖、牛奶和非营养性吸吮,这些方法虽有效,但被认为会对母乳喂养产生负面影响。全身干预措施包括包裹、襁褓、袋鼠式护理和按摩疗法。尽管这些措施在侵入性操作期间有效减轻了即时疼痛,但缺乏关于常规使用这些疗法以减少长期疼痛影响的研究。此外,还需要更多的随机对照重复研究。