Villafañe Jorge Hugo, Cantero-Tellez Raquel, Valdes Kristin, Usuelli Federico Giuseppe, Berjano Pedro
1 IRCCS Fondazione Don Carlo Gnocchi, Milan, Italy.
2 University of Málaga, Spain.
Hand (N Y). 2018 Nov;13(6):715-719. doi: 10.1177/1558944717726139. Epub 2017 Sep 14.
Conservative treatments are commonly performed therapeutic interventions for the management of carpometacarpal (CMC) joint osteoarthritis (OA). Physical and occupational therapies are starting to use video-based online content as both a patient teaching tool and a source for treatment techniques. YouTube is a popular video-sharing website that can be accessed easily. The purpose of this study was to analyze the quality of content and potential sources of bias in videos available on YouTube pertaining to thumb exercises for CMC OA.
The YouTube video database was systematically searched using the search term thumb osteoarthritis and exercises from its inception to March 10, 2017. Authors independently selected videos, conducted quality assessment, and extracted results.
A total of 832 videos were found using the keywords. Of these, 10 videos clearly demonstrated therapeutic exercise for the management of CMC OA. In addition, the top-ranked video found by performing a search of "views" was a video with more than 121 863 views uploaded in 2015 that lasted 12.33 minutes and scored only 2 points on the Global Score for Educational Value rating scale.
Most of the videos viewed that described conservative interventions for CMC OA management have a low level of evidence to support their use. Although patients and novice hand therapists are using YouTube and other online resources, videos that are produced by expert hand therapists are scarce.
保守治疗是掌指关节(CMC)骨关节炎(OA)管理中常用的治疗干预措施。物理治疗和职业治疗开始将基于视频的在线内容用作患者教育工具和治疗技术来源。YouTube是一个广受欢迎且易于访问的视频分享网站。本研究的目的是分析YouTube上与CMC OA拇指锻炼相关视频的内容质量和潜在偏倚来源。
从YouTube视频数据库创建之初至2017年3月10日,使用搜索词“拇指骨关节炎和锻炼”进行系统搜索。作者独立选择视频、进行质量评估并提取结果。
使用关键词共找到832个视频。其中,10个视频清晰展示了用于CMC OA管理的治疗性锻炼。此外,通过搜索“观看次数”找到的排名最高的视频是2015年上传的一个观看次数超过121863次的视频,时长12.33分钟,在教育价值全球评分量表上仅得2分。
大多数描述CMC OA管理保守干预措施的观看视频证据水平较低,不足以支持其使用。尽管患者和新手手部治疗师正在使用YouTube和其他在线资源,但由专业手部治疗师制作的视频却很少。