Hurren Emily, Stewart Anna, Dennison Susan
School of Criminology and Criminal Justice, Griffith Criminology Institute, Griffith University, Mt Gravatt, 4122, Australia.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2017 Sep 15;14(9):1066. doi: 10.3390/ijerph14091066.
Administrative data are crucial to the "big data" revolution of social science and have played an important role in the development of child maltreatment research. These data are also of value to administrators, policy makers, and clinicians. The focus of this paper is the use of administrative data to produce and replicate longitudinal studies of child maltreatment. Child protection administrative data have several advantages. They are often population-based, and allow longitudinal examination of child maltreatment and complex multi-level analyses. They also allow comparison across subgroups and minority groups, remove burden from individuals to disclose traumatic experiences, and can be less biased than retrospective recall. Finally, they can be linked to data from other agencies to explore comorbidity and outcomes, and are comparatively cost and time effective. The benefits and challenges associated with the use of administrative data for longitudinal child maltreatment research become magnified when these data are used to produce replications. Techniques to address challenges and support future replication efforts include developing a biographical understanding of the systems from which the data are drawn, using multiple data sources to contextualize the data and research results, recognizing and adopting various approaches to replication, and documenting all data coding and manipulation processes. These techniques are illustrated in this paper via a case study of previous replication work.
行政数据对于社会科学的“大数据”革命至关重要,并且在儿童虐待研究的发展中发挥了重要作用。这些数据对管理人员、政策制定者和临床医生也具有价值。本文的重点是利用行政数据开展和复制儿童虐待的纵向研究。儿童保护行政数据有几个优点。它们通常基于人群,允许对儿童虐待进行纵向检查和复杂的多层次分析。它们还允许对亚组和少数群体进行比较,减轻个人披露创伤经历的负担,并且可能比回顾性回忆的偏差更小。最后,它们可以与其他机构的数据相链接,以探索共病情况和结果,并且相对具有成本效益和时间效益。当这些数据用于进行复制时,与使用行政数据开展儿童虐待纵向研究相关的益处和挑战就会放大。应对挑战并支持未来复制工作的技术包括对数据来源系统形成传记式理解,使用多个数据源将数据和研究结果置于背景中,认识并采用各种复制方法,以及记录所有数据编码和处理过程。本文通过一个先前复制工作的案例研究来说明这些技术。