Centre for Social Learning and Cognitive Evolution, School of Psychology and Neuroscience, St. Andrews University, Scotland, UK; Evolutionary Anthropology Research Group and Centre for the Co-Evolution of Biology and Evolution, Department of Anthropology, Durham University, UK.
Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2017 Dec;83:429-439. doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2017.09.021. Epub 2017 Sep 22.
Speech evolution seems to defy scientific explanation. Progress on this front has been jammed in an entrenched orthodoxy about what great apes can and (mostly) cannot do vocally, an idea epitomized by the Kuypers/Jürgens hypothesis. Findings by great ape researchers paint, however, starkly different and more optimistic landscapes for speech evolution. Over twenty studies qualify as positive evidence for primate vocal (production) learning following accepted terminology. Additionally, the Kuypers/Jürgens hypothesis shows low etymological, empirical, and theoretical soundness. Great apes can produce novel voiced calls and voluntarily control their modification - observations supposedly impossible. Furthermore, no valid pretext justifies dismissing heuristically the production of new voiceless consonant-like calls by great apes. To underscore this point, new evidence is provided for a novel supra-genera voiceless call across all great ape species. Their vocal invention and vocal learning faculties are real and sufficiently potent to, at times, uphold vocal traditions. These data overpower conventional predicaments in speech evolution theory and will help to make new strides explaining why, among hominids, only humans developed speech.
言语进化似乎有违科学解释。在这方面的进展受到一种根深蒂固的传统观念的阻碍,即关于大型猿类在声音方面能做什么(主要是不能做什么),这种观点的典型代表是 Kuypers/Jürgens 假说。然而,大型猿类研究人员的发现为言语进化描绘了截然不同但更为乐观的图景。超过二十项研究符合正的证据标准,表明灵长类动物遵循公认术语进行发声(产生)学习。此外,Kuypers/Jürgens 假说在词源学、经验和理论上都缺乏合理性。大型猿类可以发出新的有声音节,并自愿控制其变化——这些观察结果据称是不可能的。此外,没有合理的借口可以从启发式的角度否定大型猿类发出新的无声音节样的叫声。为了强调这一点,提供了新的证据,证明在所有大型猿类物种中都存在一种新的超属无声叫声。它们的发声发明和发声学习能力是真实存在的,并且足够强大,有时可以维持发声传统。这些数据超越了言语进化理论中的传统困境,并将有助于取得新的进展,解释为什么在人类中只有人类发展出了言语。