Margolis Benjamin, Blinderman Craig, de Meritens Alexandre Buckley, Chatterjee-Paer Sudeshna, Ratan Rini B, Prigerson Holly G, Hou June Y, Burke William M, Wright Jason D, Tergas Ana I
1 Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, NY, USA.
2 New York Presbyterian Hospital-Columbia University Irving Medical Center, New York, NY, USA.
Am J Hosp Palliat Care. 2018 Apr;35(4):724-730. doi: 10.1177/1049909117733436. Epub 2017 Sep 26.
Obstetrics and gynecology (OB/GYN) residents receive little formal training in conducting code status discussions (CSDs).
We piloted an educational intervention to improve resident confidence and competence at conducting CSDs.
The OB/GYN residents at a single institution participated in a 3-part educational program. First, participants reviewed a journal article and completed an online module. Second, they received a didactic lecture followed by a resident-to-resident mock CSD. Finally, participants had a videotaped CSD with a standardized patient (SP). Pre- and postintervention surveys and performance evaluations were analyzed. A subgroup analysis was performed on those with completed data sets.
Participants included 24 residents in postgraduate years (PGY) 1 to 4: 85% were female with a mean age of 29 years; 83% completed the entrance survey; 63% completed the SP CSD; and 42% completed of all parts of the intervention. Residents initially felt most prepared to discuss treatment options (3.3/5 on a Likert scale) and less prepared to discuss hospice, end-of-life care, and code status (2.2/5, 2.2/5, and 2.3/5, respectively). Performance during the resident-to-resident CSD was variable with scores (% of skills achieved) ranging from 27% to 93% (mean 64%). Performance at the SP encounter was similar with scores ranging from 40% to 73% (mean 56%). After intervention, residents felt more prepared for CSDs (3.7/5) and end-of-life care (3.9/5). The subgroup analysis failed to show a significant change in skill performance from the first to the second CSD.
Participants found the components of this intervention helpful and reported improved confidence at conducting CSDs.
妇产科住院医师在进行病情告知讨论(CSD)方面接受的正规培训很少。
我们开展了一项教育干预措施,以提高住院医师进行CSD的信心和能力。
一所机构的妇产科住院医师参加了一个由三部分组成的教育项目。首先,参与者阅读一篇期刊文章并完成一个在线模块。其次,他们听取了一场理论讲座,随后进行住院医师之间的模拟CSD。最后,参与者与标准化病人(SP)进行了一场录像的CSD。对干预前后的调查和表现评估进行了分析。对拥有完整数据集的人员进行了亚组分析。
参与者包括24名1至4年级的住院医师:85%为女性,平均年龄29岁;83%完成了入学调查;63%完成了与SP的CSD;42%完成了干预的所有部分。住院医师最初觉得最有准备讨论的是治疗选择(李克特量表评分为3.3/5),而对于讨论临终关怀、临终护理和病情告知的准备程度较低(分别为2.2/5、2.2/5和2.3/5)。住院医师之间CSD的表现参差不齐,得分(技能达成率)从27%到93%不等(平均64%)。与SP接触时的表现类似,得分从40%到73%不等(平均56%)。干预后,住院医师对CSD(3.7/5)和临终护理(3.9/5)感觉更有准备。亚组分析未显示从第一次到第二次CSD技能表现有显著变化。
参与者认为该干预措施的各个部分很有帮助,并报告称进行CSD的信心有所提高。