Malhi Saima Mahmood, Raza Hassan, Ajmal Kiran, Shamim Sumbul, Ata Saniya, Farooq Salman, Sharib Syed Muhammad, Muntaha Sidrat-Ul
Faculty of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Dow College of Pharmacy, Dow University of Health Sciences, OJHA Campus, Karachi 74200, Pakistan.
Pharmacy (Basel). 2017 Aug 17;5(3):46. doi: 10.3390/pharmacy5030046.
: Good curriculum is reflected as the backbone for standard universities to develop competitive professionals having great potential. Pharmacy education in Pakistan has gone through the same developmental stages as in other countries, but is still striving for improvement. In the present study, we want (i) to know the opinion on whether the current pharmacy curriculum requires any improvement in order to meet the training needs of pharmacy professionals regarding clinical knowledge and pharmacy practice; and (ii) to present some humble suggestions to decision-making authorities in order to improve it with respect to patient-focused programs (PFP). : The study was conducted in two sessions. In first session, a questionnaire was distributed to pharmacy students of eight public/private sector universities of Karachi ( = 354) offering Pharm. D degrees. The second session dealt with the pharmacy teachers, deans, and practicing pharmacists in health care facilities (who are in any ways also related to academia), in order to take their opinions on and suggestions for the development of a better Pharm. D curriculum ( = 135). : Our results showed that 75.2% of respondents agree that the Pharm. D curriculum does not meet the international standards of practice, and 88.4% of respondents support the addition of more clinical aspects than industrial ones, as Pharm. D could be both clinically and industrially oriented, according to the needs of the Pakistani people. Furthermore, 80.2% of respondents are of the view that an apprenticeship should be included in last two years, while 88.4% demand a 'paid residency program' to facilitate the hospital, clinical and compounding areas of pharmacy. In addition, we also received a number of verbal suggestions for improving the Pharm. D curriculum being followed in Pakistan. : We conclude that our Pharm. D curriculum needs additions in terms of clinical practice by providing residencies and electives in health care settings. Accordingly, the need for a clinically oriented curriculum is highlighted in Pakistan, keeping in mind the continuing importance of the industrial viewpoint. Various studies have criticized the pharmacy curriculum in Pakistan in the past. Conversely, we suggest some changes in the curriculum, as change is always needed for a better tomorrow.
优质课程是标准大学培养具有巨大潜力的有竞争力专业人才的支柱。巴基斯坦的药学教育经历了与其他国家相同的发展阶段,但仍在努力改进。在本研究中,我们希望:(i)了解当前药学课程是否需要改进以满足药学专业人员在临床知识和药学实践方面的培训需求;(ii)向决策机构提出一些拙见,以便在以患者为中心的项目(PFP)方面对其进行改进。
本研究分两个阶段进行。在第一阶段,向卡拉奇八所公立/私立大学(n = 354)提供药学博士学位的药学专业学生发放了问卷。第二阶段涉及药学教师、院长以及医疗机构中的执业药师(他们在某种程度上也与学术界相关),以便征求他们对制定更好的药学博士课程的意见和建议(n = 135)。
我们的结果表明,75.2%的受访者认为药学博士课程不符合国际实践标准,88.4%的受访者支持增加更多临床方面而非工业方面的内容,因为根据巴基斯坦人民的需求,药学博士可以兼顾临床和工业导向。此外,80.2%的受访者认为最后两年应纳入学徒制,88.4%的受访者要求设立“带薪住院医师项目”以促进药学的医院、临床和配药领域的发展。此外,我们还收到了一些关于改进巴基斯坦现行药学博士课程的口头建议。
我们得出结论,我们的药学博士课程需要通过在医疗机构提供住院医师培训和选修课来增加临床实践方面的内容。因此,巴基斯坦强调了以临床为导向的课程的必要性,同时铭记工业视角的持续重要性。过去,各种研究都批评了巴基斯坦的药学课程。相反,我们建议对课程进行一些改变,因为为了更美好的明天总是需要变革的。