Heidi Allen (
Ashley Swanson is an assistant professor of health care management and the Wharton School Senior Fellow at the Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics, both at the University of Pennsylvania, in Philadelphia.
Health Aff (Millwood). 2017 Oct 1;36(10):1769-1776. doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2017.0369.
We examined the impact of California's early Medicaid expansion under the Affordable Care Act on the use of payday loans, a form of high-interest borrowing used by low- and middle-income Americans. Using a data set for the period 2009-13 (roughly twenty-four months before and twenty-four months after the 2011-12 Medicaid expansion) that covered the universe of payday loans from five large payday lenders with locations around the United States, we used a difference-in-differences research design to assess the effect of the expansion on payday borrowing, comparing trends in early-expansion counties in California to those in counties nationwide that did not expand early. The early Medicaid expansion was associated with an 11 percent reduction in the number of loans taken out each month. It also reduced the number of unique borrowers each month and the amount of payday loan debt. We were unable to determine precisely how and for whom the expansion reduced payday borrowing, since to our knowledge, no data exist that directly link payday lending to insurance status. Nonetheless, our results suggest that Medicaid reduced the demand for high-interest loans and improved the financial health of American families.
我们考察了《平价医疗法案》下加州早期扩大医疗补助计划对发薪日贷款使用情况的影响,发薪日贷款是一种被美国家庭,尤其是低收入和中等收入群体使用的高息借贷形式。我们使用了一个涵盖全美五家大型发薪日贷款机构所在地的发薪日贷款数据集,数据时间跨度为 2009 年至 2013 年(大致在 2011-12 年医疗补助计划扩张前 24 个月和扩张后 24 个月),采用双重差分研究设计来评估扩张对发薪日贷款的影响,将加州早期扩张县与全国范围内没有早期扩张的县的趋势进行比较。早期医疗补助计划的扩张与每月发放的贷款数量减少 11%有关。它还减少了每月的独特借款人数量和发薪日贷款债务。由于据我们所知,没有数据直接将发薪日贷款与保险状况联系起来,因此我们无法准确确定扩张是如何以及为何减少了发薪日贷款。尽管如此,我们的研究结果表明,医疗补助计划减少了对高息贷款的需求,改善了美国家庭的财务健康状况。