Mila-Kierzenkowska Celestyna, Woźniak Alina, Krzyżyńska-Malinowska Ewa, Kałużna Lucyna, Wesołowski Roland, Poćwiardowski Wojciech, Owcarz Marcin
The Chair of Medical Biology, Collegium Medicum of Nicolaus Copernicus University, Bydgoszcz, Poland.
Department of Cosmetology, Torun Higher School of Business, Toruń, Poland.
J Arthropod Borne Dis. 2017 Mar 14;11(1):1-9. eCollection 2017 Mar.
Scabies is an ectoparasitic infection, which occurs because of direct skin-to skin contact. The ideal treatment modality is still unclear and further research on this topic is warranted. The aim of the study was to compare the efficacy and safety of the topical scabicides: permethrin, crotamiton and sulfur ointment.
Fifty four patients with diagnosed scabies were randomly divided into three treatment groups. The first group received 5% permethrin cream twice with one week interval, the patients from the second group were given crotamiton lotion for two days twice with one week interval, while the third group received 10% sulfur ointment for two or three weeks. All patients were followed up at 1, 2 and 4 weeks intervals.
At one-week follow up the cure rate was significantly higher at permethrin-treated group when compared to crotamiton group (P< 0.001) and sulfur group (P< 0.001). At the end of two-week interval, the cure rate at permethrin group was 100%, while at crotamiton group, 66.7% and in sulfur group 38.9% (P< 0.001). At 4-week follow up the applied treatment was effective in all studied individuals.
The topical application of permethrin, crotamiton and sulfur was equally efficacious at 4-week follow up, however permethrin cream showed faster improvement at first and second follow up. Acquiring permethrin is considered as expensive option and crotamiton lotion seems to be cost-less alternative to this cream.
疥疮是一种由直接皮肤接触引起的外寄生虫感染。理想的治疗方式仍不明确,对此主题进行进一步研究很有必要。本研究的目的是比较外用杀疥剂:氯菊酯、克罗米通和硫磺软膏的疗效和安全性。
54例确诊为疥疮的患者被随机分为三个治疗组。第一组每隔一周使用两次5%氯菊酯乳膏,第二组患者每隔一周使用两天克罗米通洗剂,第三组使用10%硫磺软膏两周或三周。所有患者每隔1、2和4周进行随访。
在一周的随访中,氯菊酯治疗组的治愈率显著高于克罗米通组(P<0.001)和硫磺组(P<0.001)。在两周间隔结束时,氯菊酯组的治愈率为100%,而克罗米通组为66.7%,硫磺组为38.9%(P<0.001)。在4周的随访中,所有研究对象所采用的治疗均有效。
在4周的随访中,外用氯菊酯、克罗米通和硫磺同样有效,然而氯菊酯乳膏在第一次和第二次随访时改善更快。获取氯菊酯被认为是一种昂贵的选择,而克罗米通洗剂似乎是这种乳膏的低成本替代品。