Department of Radiology, University of Washington Medical Center, 1959 NE Pacific Street, Seattle, WA, 98195, USA.
Department of Radiology, Tata Memorial Center, E Borges Road, Parel, Mumbai, 400012, India.
Abdom Radiol (NY). 2018 Jul;43(7):1764-1771. doi: 10.1007/s00261-017-1357-3.
To compare contrast-enhanced CT and US agreement in characterizing adnexal lesions in late post-menopausal women.
This was a HIPAA-compliant IRB-approved retrospective review of the contrast-enhanced CTs of 130 late post-menopausal women (> 55 years). The lesions were classified as simple cystic, minimally complex cystic, complex cystic, solid-cystic, or solid based on CT and US morphology. Findings were analyzed to evaluate agreement between CT and US on adnexal lesion characterization.
One forty-one adnexal lesions were assessed by both contrast-enhanced CT and US. Overall, there was good agreement between CT and US, which agreed on the lesion morphology in 114 (81%) cases with an unweighted kappa value of 0.68 (95% CI 0.56-0.78). By CT, 83 (59%) were classified as simple cystic, of which 73/83 (88%) were confirmed as simple cystic by US. Of the remaining 10 CT simple cysts, 9 were reclassified by US as minimally complex cystic and one as complex cystic. Eight of these lesions were benign based on pathology or follow-up imaging, while two lesions remained indeterminate. By CT, 27 lesions (19%) were classified as minimally complex, while US reclassified 13 (48%) of the lesions (eight to simple cystic and five as complex or solid-cystic). Among the 31 remaining lesions, there were 4 (13%) discordances between CT and US.
There is good agreement between CT and US in characterizing adnexal lesion morphology, particularly simple cysts. However, there was significant discordance seen with characterization of minimally complex cysts, indicating that these lesions need US follow-up.
比较增强 CT 和 US 在诊断绝经后晚期女性附件病变中的一致性。
本研究为 HIPAA 合规性、IRB 批准的回顾性研究,纳入 130 例绝经后晚期 (>55 岁) 女性的增强 CT 检查结果。根据 CT 和 US 形态学,将病变分为单纯性囊肿、轻度复杂性囊肿、复杂性囊肿、实性-囊性或实性。分析这些发现以评估 CT 和 US 在附件病变特征描述方面的一致性。
共有 141 个附件病变同时接受增强 CT 和 US 检查。总的来说,CT 和 US 之间存在良好的一致性,在 114 例病变中 CT 和 US 对病变形态的判断一致,未加权 Kappa 值为 0.68(95%CI 0.56-0.78)。根据 CT,83 个病变被归类为单纯性囊肿,其中 73/83(88%)被 US 证实为单纯性囊肿。在剩下的 10 个 CT 单纯性囊肿中,9 个被 US 重新归类为轻度复杂性囊肿,1 个为复杂性囊肿。这些病变中有 8 个基于病理或随访影像学为良性,2 个仍不确定。根据 CT,27 个病变(19%)被归类为轻度复杂性,而 US 重新分类了 13 个(48%)病变(8 个为单纯性囊肿,5 个为复杂性或实性-囊性)。在剩下的 31 个病变中,CT 和 US 之间存在 4 个(13%)不一致。
CT 和 US 在描述附件病变形态方面具有良好的一致性,尤其是单纯性囊肿。然而,在轻度复杂性囊肿的描述方面存在显著的不一致,这表明这些病变需要 US 随访。