Kemper Alex R, Barnett Elizabeth D, Walter Emmanuel B, Hornik Christoph, Pierre-Joseph Natalie, Broder Karen R, Silverstein Michael, Harrington Theresa
Division of Ambulatory Pediatrics, Nationwide Children's Hospital, Columbus, Ohio;
Department of Pediatrics, School of Medicine, Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts.
Pediatrics. 2017 Nov;140(5). doi: 10.1542/peds.2017-0508.
Postvaccination syncope can cause injury. Drinking water prephlebotomy increases peripheral vascular tone, decreasing risk of blood-donation presyncope and syncope. This study evaluated whether drinking water prevaccination reduces postvaccination presyncope, a potential syncope precursor.
We conducted a randomized trial of subjects aged 11 to 21 years receiving ≥1 intramuscular vaccine in primary care clinics. Intervention subjects were encouraged to drink 500 mL of water, with vaccination recommended 10 to 60 minutes later. Control subjects received usual care. Presyncope symptoms were assessed with a 12-item survey during the 20-minutes postvaccination. Symptoms were classified with a primary cutoff sensitive for presyncope, and a secondary, more restrictive cutoff requiring greater symptoms. Results were adjusted for clustering by recruitment center.
There were 906 subjects randomly assigned to the control group and 901 subjects randomly assigned to the intervention group. None had syncope. Presyncope occurred in 36.2% of subjects by using the primary definition, and in 8.0% of subjects by using the restrictive definition. There were no significant differences in presyncope by intervention group for the primary (1-sided test, = .24) or restrictive outcome (1-sided test, = .17). Among intervention subjects vaccinated within 10 to 60 minutes after drinking all 500 mL of water ( = 519), no reduction in presyncope was observed for the primary or restrictive outcome (1-sided tests, = .13, = .17). In multivariable regression analysis, presyncope was associated with younger age, history of passing out or nearly passing out after a shot or blood draw, prevaccination anxiety, receiving >1 injected vaccine, and greater postvaccination pain.
Drinking water before vaccination did not prevent postvaccination presyncope. Predictors of postvaccination presyncope suggest opportunities for presyncope and syncope prevention interventions.
接种疫苗后晕厥可能导致受伤。静脉穿刺前饮水可增加外周血管张力,降低献血前晕厥和晕厥的风险。本研究评估接种疫苗前饮水是否能减少接种疫苗后前驱晕厥(一种潜在的晕厥先兆)。
我们在初级保健诊所对11至21岁接受≥1剂肌肉注射疫苗的受试者进行了一项随机试验。鼓励干预组受试者饮用500毫升水,建议在10至60分钟后进行疫苗接种。对照组受试者接受常规护理。在接种疫苗后的20分钟内,通过一项包含12个项目的调查评估前驱晕厥症状。症状根据对前驱晕厥敏感的主要临界值以及要求症状更严重的次要、更严格临界值进行分类。结果针对招募中心的聚类情况进行了调整。
906名受试者被随机分配到对照组,901名受试者被随机分配到干预组。无人发生晕厥。按照主要定义,36.2%的受试者出现前驱晕厥;按照严格定义,8.0%的受试者出现前驱晕厥。干预组在前驱晕厥方面,无论是主要结果(单侧检验,P = 0.24)还是严格结果(单侧检验,P = 0.17),均无显著差异。在饮用完所有500毫升水后10至60分钟内接种疫苗的干预组受试者中(n = 519),无论是主要结果还是严格结果,均未观察到前驱晕厥减少(单侧检验,P = 0.13,P = 0.17)。在多变量回归分析中,前驱晕厥与年龄较小、打针或抽血后有晕倒或几乎晕倒史、接种疫苗前焦虑、接受>1剂注射疫苗以及接种疫苗后疼痛加剧有关。
接种疫苗前饮水并不能预防接种疫苗后前驱晕厥。接种疫苗后前驱晕厥的预测因素提示了进行前驱晕厥和晕厥预防干预的机会。