Davis Konrad, Perry-Moseanko Alexandra, Tadlock Matthew D, Henry Nichole, Pamplin Jeremy
Department of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Naval Medical Center San Diego, 34800 Bob Wilson Drive, San Diego, CA 92134.
Department of Surgery, Naval Hospital Camp Pendleton, 200 Mercy Circle, Camp Pendleton, CA 92055.
Mil Med. 2017 May;182(5):e1702-e1707. doi: 10.7205/MILMED-D-16-00277.
Intensivist physician involvement has been shown to improve outcomes for critically ill patients. Unfortunately, the number of Intensivists nationally is unable to meet the current demand. Similar to the civilian community, the Navy critical care workforce is limited by available resources. Tele-critical care (TCC) has recently been shown to improve outcomes for critically ill patients, and has been suggested as a suitable means of extending Intensivist expertise. Naval Hospital Camp Pendleton (NHCP) is a small community hospital located 41 miles north of Naval Medical Center San Diego (NMCSD). NHCP operates a relatively low-volume six-bed medical-surgical intensive care unit. The Intensivist staffing of NHCP has been variable, ranging from 3 Intensivists to periods of time with no on-site Intensivists. This intermittent staffing has led to (1) network disengagements, (2) unnecessary transfers to NMCSD, and (3) adverse outcomes for critically ill patients cared for at NHCP without Intensivist involvement. In early 2014, NMCSD established a TCC system to address this staffing challenge. Through the TCC program, the tele-Intensivist at NMCSD provides 24/7 coverage for patients located at NHCP using low-cost, off-the-shelf, synchronous high-definition video-teleconferencing equipment, and remote access to electronic medical record, imaging studies, and laboratory data. The tele-Intensivist also participates in multidisciplinary teaching rounds with the NHCP house staff. Several medical protocols have also been developed and implemented as part of the TCC program. When comparing the 12 months before implementation with the 19 months following implementation, we found (1) a trend toward increase volume of admissions per month (22.9 ± 7.5 vs. 27 ± 6.6, p = 0.11), (2) a decrease in total number of avoidable disengagements (12 ± 0.9 vs. 0, p = 0.0008), (3) increased maximum Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation II score per month (17.22 ± 2.2 vs. 21.8 ± 5.5, p = 0.018), and no adverse outcomes related to the TCC system. This reduction in disengagements correlated with a savings in out-of-network expenditures of $1.3 million over the 19 months of program operation. There was no change in either the patients' length of stay or the number of patients transferred to NMCSD. TCC improves readiness by increasing the volume and acuity of critical care patient encounters at the spoke hospital. TCC can also enhance Graduate Medical Education by providing Intensivist teaching, and supports the concept of "Regionalized Care" by improving the integration of care between hospitals. The quality of care is improved through the more rapid transfer of patients who require a higher level of care, standardization of care through protocols, and the Intensivist expertise that is applied to patients kept at the smaller facility. The value of care increased through both enhanced quality, and the cost savings associated with decreasing network disengagements. Leveraging new technology to provide remote care for our sickest beneficiaries has been proven a successful solution to the dilemma of limited Intensivist staffing. Leadership should consider TCC as a tool to extend Intensivist expertise to all of our small hospitals, and should explore the application of synchronous telehealth within the operational environment where similar staffing challenges exist.
重症医学科医生的参与已被证明可改善重症患者的治疗结果。不幸的是,全国范围内重症医学科医生的数量无法满足当前需求。与平民社区类似,海军重症监护人力也受到可用资源的限制。远程重症监护(TCC)最近已被证明可改善重症患者的治疗结果,并被认为是扩展重症医学科医生专业知识的合适手段。彭德尔顿海军陆战队基地医院(NHCP)是一家小型社区医院,位于圣地亚哥海军医疗中心(NMCSD)以北41英里处。NHCP运营着一个床位相对较少的六床内科-外科重症监护病房。NHCP的重症医学科医生配备情况不一,从3名重症医学科医生到有时没有现场重症医学科医生。这种间歇性的人员配备导致了:(1)网络脱节;(2)不必要地转至NMCSD;(3)在NHCP接受治疗且没有重症医学科医生参与的重症患者出现不良治疗结果。2014年初,NMCSD建立了一个TCC系统来应对这一人员配备挑战。通过TCC项目,NMCSD的远程重症医学科医生使用低成本、现成的同步高清视频电话会议设备,为NHCP的患者提供全天候覆盖,并可远程访问电子病历、影像研究和实验室数据。远程重症医学科医生还与NHCP的住院医师一起参加多学科教学查房。作为TCC项目的一部分,还制定并实施了一些医疗协议。将实施前的12个月与实施后的19个月进行比较时,我们发现:(1)每月入院量有增加趋势(22.9±7.5对27±6.6,p = 0.11);(2)可避免的脱节总数减少(12±0.9对0,p = 0.0008);(3)每月急性生理学与慢性健康状况评估II(APACHE II)最高评分增加(17.22±2.2对21.8±5.5,p = 0.018),且没有与TCC系统相关的不良治疗结果。这种脱节的减少与项目运行的19个月期间节省了130万美元的网络外支出相关。患者的住院时间和转至NMCSD的患者数量均无变化。TCC通过增加基层医院重症监护患者的数量和病情严重程度来提高应急准备能力。TCC还可通过提供重症医学科医生教学来加强毕业后医学教育,并通过改善医院间的医疗整合来支持“区域化医疗”的理念。通过更快速地转运需要更高水平治疗的患者、通过协议实现医疗标准化以及将重症医学科医生的专业知识应用于留在较小医疗机构的患者,医疗质量得到了提高。通过提高质量以及与减少网络脱节相关的成本节约,医疗价值得以提升。利用新技术为病情最严重的受益人提供远程医疗已被证明是解决重症医学科医生人员配备有限这一困境的成功方案。领导层应将TCC视为将重症医学科医生专业知识扩展到我们所有小型医院的一种工具,并应探索在存在类似人员配备挑战的作战环境中应用同步远程医疗。