Barcia Anthony M, Zhou Liang, Cook Jay B, Lindell Kenneth K, Gumboc Rey D, Dykstra Aaron D, Lachky Robert J, Shaha Steven H, Taylor Kenneth F
Orthopedics. 2017 Nov 1;40(6):e1092-e1095. doi: 10.3928/01477447-20171020-05.
Diagnosis of occult scaphoid fractures remains a challenge. Traditional management consisting of 2 weeks of immobilization and repeat radiographs results in unnecessary immobilization of many patients without fracture. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is sensitive but expensive. Digital tomography (DT) is an imaging technique that provides fine-cut visualization with minimal radiation exposure and may be used when there is high clinical suspicion despite negative findings on initial radiographs. The authors compared the ability of DT vs MRI to detect acute occult scaphoid fractures. This was an institutional review board-approved, prospective series. Adults for which clinical suspicion for acute scaphoid fracture (presenting within 96 hours of trauma) and negative findings on initial radiographs existed were included. Both a wrist tomogram and MRI were obtained. Wrists were immobilized and reevaluated at 10 to 14 days with repeat radiographs as a control. Studies were interpreted by a radiologist in a blinded fashion. Forty consecutive extremities in 39 patients met the inclusion criteria. Six (15%) of the 40 scaphoids were determined to be fractured on repeat radiographs. Digital tomogram yielded positive findings in 4 of these. Magnetic resonance imaging yielded positive findings in 8 (20%) of the 40 extremities. Sensitivities were 67% and 100% for digital tomogram and MRI, respectively (P=.0001). The positive predictive value was 100% for DT and MRI. The authors found that DT detects more occult scaphoid fractures than initial standard radiographs but is less sensitive than MRI. This is the first study to compare DT with MRI. Digital tomography can be used to augment radiographs and may increase diagnostic efficiency, minimize unnecessary immobilization, and reduce health care costs. [Orthopedics. 2017; 40(6):e1092-e1095.].
隐匿性舟状骨骨折的诊断仍然是一项挑战。传统的处理方法是固定2周并复查X线片,这会导致许多未骨折的患者被不必要地固定。磁共振成像(MRI)虽敏感但费用高昂。数字断层扫描(DT)是一种成像技术,能以最小的辐射暴露提供精细的断层可视化,当临床高度怀疑而初始X线片结果为阴性时可使用。作者比较了DT与MRI检测急性隐匿性舟状骨骨折的能力。这是一项经机构审查委员会批准的前瞻性系列研究。纳入了临床怀疑急性舟状骨骨折(创伤后96小时内就诊)且初始X线片结果为阴性的成年人。同时进行了腕部断层扫描和MRI检查。腕部进行固定,并在10至14天时复查X线片作为对照进行重新评估。研究由一名放射科医生以盲法解读。39例患者的40个连续肢体符合纳入标准。40个舟状骨中有6个(15%)在复查X线片时被判定骨折。其中4个在数字断层扫描中有阳性发现。40个肢体中有8个(20%)在MRI中有阳性发现。数字断层扫描和MRI的敏感度分别为67%和100%(P = 0.0001)。DT和MRI的阳性预测值均为100%。作者发现,DT比初始标准X线片能检测出更多隐匿性舟状骨骨折,但不如MRI敏感。这是第一项比较DT与MRI的研究。数字断层扫描可用于辅助X线片检查,可能提高诊断效率,减少不必要的固定,并降低医疗成本。[《骨科学》。2017年;40(6):e1092 - e1095。]