Henry Brandon Michael, Marcinów Agata, Pękala Przemysław, Taterra Dominik, Loukas Marios, Tubbs R Shane, Walocha Jerzy A, Tomaszewski Krzysztof A
Department of Anatomy, Jagiellonian University Medical College, Kopernika 12, Kraków, Poland.
Folia Med Cracov. 2017;57(2):105-116.
Recently, an improvement of the quality of reporting and methodology in original research has been observed. Major fields in research have introduced checklists aimed at promoting clear and univocal reporting of methods and results. The basis of evidence-based medicine (EBM) lies in transparent reporting of primary studies. Although clinical research progressed rapidly into evidence-based guidelines, the basic sciences, including anatomy, just recently started to use the rules of EBM. No anatomy-specific standardized research checklist has been introduced so far. Evidence-based anatomy (EBA) emerged as a new approach to research in anatomy that incorporates methods, such as meta-analysis and systematic review. High quality methodology and clear reporting of results of original studies are the basis of EBA. The Anatomical Quality Assurance (AQUA) Checklist is a new tool aimed to introduce univocal reporting of original anatomical studies. The checklist consists of 29 reporting items, which are essential in obtaining unambiguous and high-quality reporting of methods and results and ensuing straightforward interpretation and reproducibility. The AQUA Checklists been endorsed by anatomical associations, including the International Federation of Associations of Anatomists. Therefore, the authors of this study believe that introduction of the Polish version of AQUA Checklist into practice will improve the quality of original anatomical studies in Poland and will promote the EBA standards for years to come.
最近,人们观察到原创研究的报告质量和方法有了改进。主要研究领域引入了清单,旨在促进对方法和结果进行清晰明确的报告。循证医学(EBM)的基础在于对原始研究的透明报告。尽管临床研究迅速发展为循证指南,但包括解剖学在内的基础科学直到最近才开始采用循证医学的规则。到目前为止,尚未引入针对解剖学的标准化研究清单。循证解剖学(EBA)作为解剖学研究的一种新方法出现,它纳入了荟萃分析和系统评价等方法。高质量的方法和对原创研究结果的清晰报告是EBA的基础。解剖学质量保证(AQUA)清单是一种新工具,旨在引入对原始解剖学研究的明确报告。该清单由29个报告项目组成,这些项目对于获得关于方法和结果的明确且高质量的报告以及随后的直接解释和可重复性至关重要。AQUA清单已得到包括国际解剖学家协会联合会在内的解剖学协会的认可。因此,本研究的作者认为,将波兰语版的AQUA清单引入实践将提高波兰原始解剖学研究的质量,并在未来几年推广EBA标准。