Leon Monica, Chavez Luis Omar, Einav Sharon, Varon Joseph
Dorrington Medical Associated, Houston, Texas, USA.
Faculty of Medicine, Universidad Popular Autonoma del Estado de Puebla, Puebla, Mexico.
Indian J Palliat Care. 2017 Oct-Dec;23(4):363-367. doi: 10.4103/IJPC.IJPC_21_17.
To study whether health-care workers feel capable of making resuscitation decisions for their own families, the confidence in their family to represent their own preferences, and if some health-care workers feel greater confidence in their ability to undertake such decisions for their family than others.
An anonymous survey conducted among health-care workers of nine institutions in North and Central America. The self-administered questionnaire included demographic and professional characteristics, attitudes, personal preferences, and value judgments on the topic of resuscitation.
Eight hundred and fifty-eight surveys were completed; 21.1% by physicians, 37.2% by nurses, and 41.7% by other health-care. Most of the health-care workers (83.5%) stated that they should be unable to determine their own code status and they would allow their family or spouse/significant other to make this decision for themselves. Physicians felt significantly more capable of making a decision regarding the code status of a close family member than other hospital workers ( = 0.019). Professionals who chose to not undergo cardiopulmonary resuscitation were less likely to feel capable of determining the code status of their family.
Most of the health-care workers feel capable of making code status decisions for a close family member and most feel equally comfortable having their family or spouse/significant other represent their code status preference should they be incapacitated. There is considerable reciprocity between the two situations. Physicians feel more confident in their ability to make code status decisions for their loved ones than other health-care workers. Regardless of profession, a personal preference for do not attempt resuscitation status is related to less confidence.
研究医护人员是否认为自己有能力为家人做出复苏决策,家人代表自己意愿的信心程度,以及是否有一些医护人员比其他人对为家人做出此类决策更有信心。
对北美和中美洲9个机构的医护人员进行匿名调查。自行填写的问卷包括人口统计学和专业特征、态度、个人偏好以及关于复苏主题的价值判断。
共完成858份调查问卷;医生占21.1%,护士占37.2%,其他医护人员占41.7%。大多数医护人员(83.5%)表示他们无法确定自己的急救状态,会让家人或配偶/重要他人为自己做出这一决定。与其他医院工作人员相比,医生认为自己更有能力就亲密家庭成员的急救状态做出决定(P = 0.019)。选择不接受心肺复苏的专业人员认为自己有能力确定家人急救状态的可能性较小。
大多数医护人员认为自己有能力为亲密家庭成员做出急救状态决策,并且大多数人认为如果自己丧失行为能力,让家人或配偶/重要他人代表自己的急救状态偏好也同样自在。这两种情况之间存在相当程度的对等性。与其他医护人员相比,医生对为亲人做出急救状态决策更有信心。无论职业如何,个人对不尝试复苏状态的偏好与信心较低有关。