University of Michigan, Department of Surgery, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
University of Michigan, Department of Surgery, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Am J Surg. 2018 Feb;215(2):293-297. doi: 10.1016/j.amjsurg.2017.08.047. Epub 2017 Nov 4.
Medical students often report dissatisfaction with the feedback they receive on their clerkships. This study evaluates the performance of the Minute Feedback System (MFS), a web-based tool designed to facilitate medical student acquisition of same day written feedback from surgery residents and faculty.
System-generated data, targeted surveys, and end of clerkship questionnaires were used to evaluate MFS performance over a one-year period.
170 students made 3190 feedback requests and received 1978 responses (62% response rate). Students felt the system was easy to use (90%), provided useful feedback (74%), and allowed them to obtain more feedback than they would have in its absence (81%). Concerns were raised regarding the quality of electronic feedback and whether the data generated would be used for summative assessment.
The MFS encourages same-day assessment and increases documented medical student feedback. Further development is required to improve feedback quality, response rates, and feedback application.
医学生经常对他们在实习期间收到的反馈不满意。本研究评估了 Minute Feedback System（MFS）的性能，这是一个基于网络的工具，旨在促进医学生从外科住院医师和教师那里获得当天的书面反馈。
系统生成的数据、有针对性的调查和实习结束问卷用于评估 MFS 在一年期间的性能。
170 名学生提出了 3190 次反馈请求，收到了 1978 次回复（回复率为 62%）。学生认为该系统易于使用（90%），提供了有用的反馈（74%），并允许他们获得比没有该系统时更多的反馈（81%）。有人对电子反馈的质量以及生成的数据是否将用于总结性评估表示担忧。
MFS 鼓励当天评估，并增加了记录的医学生反馈。需要进一步开发以提高反馈质量、回复率和反馈应用。
