Chang Yi-Tzu, Ku Li-Chuan, Chen Hsueh-Chih
Department of Educational Psychology and Counseling, National Taiwan Normal University, Taipei, Taiwan.
Department of Educational Psychology and Counseling, National Taiwan Normal University, Taipei, Taiwan.
Brain Cogn. 2018 Feb;120:34-42. doi: 10.1016/j.bandc.2017.11.002. Epub 2017 Nov 16.
Numerous behavioral studies and a handful of functional neuroimaging studies have reported sex differences in humor. However, no study to date has examined differences in the time-course of brain activity during multistage humor processing between the sexes. The purpose of this study was to compare real-time dynamics related to humor processing between women and men, with reference to a proposed three-stage model (involving incongruity detection, incongruity resolution, and elaboration stages). Forty undergraduate students (20 women) underwent event-related potential recording while subjectively rating 30 question-answer-type jokes and 30 question-answer-type statements in a random order. Sex differences were revealed by analyses of the mean amplitudes of difference waves during a specific time window between 1000 and 1300 ms poststimulus onset (P1000-1300). This indicates that women recruited more mental resources to integrate cognitive and emotional components at this late stage. In contrast, men recruited more automated processes during the transition from the cognitive operations of the incongruity resolution stage to the emotional response of the humor elaboration stage. Our results suggest that sex differences in humor processing lie in differences in the integration of cognitive and emotional components, which are closely linked and interact reciprocally, particularly in women.
大量行为学研究以及少量功能性神经影像学研究均报告了幽默方面的性别差异。然而,迄今为止尚无研究考察两性在多阶段幽默加工过程中大脑活动时间进程的差异。本研究的目的是参照一个提出的三阶段模型(包括不一致性检测、不一致性解决和 elaboration 阶段),比较男女在与幽默加工相关的实时动态。40 名本科生(20 名女性)在以随机顺序主观评定 30 个问答型笑话和 30 个问答型陈述时接受了事件相关电位记录。通过对刺激开始后 1000 至 1300 毫秒特定时间窗口内差异波平均振幅的分析揭示了性别差异(P1000 - 1300)。这表明女性在这个后期阶段调动了更多心理资源来整合认知和情感成分。相比之下,男性在从不一致性解决阶段的认知操作向幽默 elaboration 阶段的情感反应转变过程中调动了更多自动化过程。我们的结果表明,幽默加工中的性别差异在于认知和情感成分整合的差异,这些成分紧密相连且相互作用,在女性中尤为如此。