Yucesoy Can A, Ateş Filiz
Biomedical Engineering Institute, Boğaziçi University, Istanbul, Turkey.
Biomedical Engineering Institute, Boğaziçi University, Istanbul, Turkey; Mayo Clinic, Rochester, USA.
J Biomech. 2018 Jan 3;66:78-85. doi: 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2017.10.035. Epub 2017 Nov 6.
Botulinum toxin type-A (BTX-A) is widely used in treating gastrocnemius medial (GM) and lateral (GL) muscles in cerebral palsy to improve joint motion. However, recent animal experiments indicate inferior BTX-A effects beyond the injected muscle. The goal was to test the following hypotheses in a rat model. (1) BTX-A injected into the GM and GL does not spread into the soleus (SOL), and muscles exposed show (2) a wider length range of force exertion (L), (3) reduced passive forces and (4) no intermuscular interaction effects. Confirming them was considered to indicate BTX-A effects in agreement with the treatment aims and confined to the target muscles. Two groups of Wistar rats were tested: Control (no BTX-A injected) and BTX (0.1 units of BTX-A were injected to the GM and GL, each). GM-GL and SOL muscle distal isometric forces were measured after GM-GL lengthening (condition-1, in which SOL length was kept constant) and with added SOL lengthening (condition-2). Five-days post, BTX-A injection caused significant effects: (1) all muscles showed force drops (minimally by 45%) indicating spread into the SOL. (2) L of GM-GL (conditions-1 and 2) and SOL (condition-2) decreased (up to 25%). (3) Passive forces showed no change (condition-1) or opposite-coupled changes for the GM-GL (decrease by 26.6%) and SOL (increase by 25.4%) (condition-2). Intramuscular connective tissues of all muscles increased. (4) Intermuscular interactions affected BTX-A effects (e.g., GM-GL force drop increased by 48.7% in condition-2 vs. 1). Rejected hypotheses indicate complex widespread BTX-A effects contradicting some treatment aims, hence clinical testing.
A型肉毒杆菌毒素(BTX-A)被广泛用于治疗脑瘫患者的腓肠肌内侧(GM)和外侧(GL)肌肉,以改善关节活动。然而,最近的动物实验表明,BTX-A在注射肌肉之外的效果较差。本研究旨在在大鼠模型中检验以下假设。(1)注射到GM和GL的BTX-A不会扩散到比目鱼肌(SOL),且暴露的肌肉显示(2)力施加的长度范围(L)更宽,(3)被动力降低,以及(4)不存在肌肉间相互作用效应。证实这些假设被认为表明BTX-A的效果符合治疗目标且局限于目标肌肉。对两组Wistar大鼠进行了测试:对照组(未注射BTX-A)和BTX组(分别向GM和GL注射0.1单位的BTX-A)。在GM-GL延长后(条件1,其中SOL长度保持恒定)以及增加SOL延长后(条件2),测量GM-GL和SOL肌肉远端的等长力。BTX-A注射后5天,产生了显著影响:(1)所有肌肉均出现力下降(至少下降45%),表明扩散到了SOL。(2)GM-GL(条件1和2)和SOL(条件2)的L降低(最多降低25%)。(3)被动力在条件1下无变化,而在条件2下,GM-GL(下降26.6%)和SOL(增加25.4%)出现相反的耦合变化。所有肌肉的肌内结缔组织均增加。(4)肌肉间相互作用影响了BTX-A的效果(例如,与条件1相比,条件2下GM-GL的力下降增加了48.7%)。被否定的假设表明BTX-A存在复杂的广泛效应,与某些治疗目标相矛盾,因此需要进行临床试验。