Steinman R T, Herrera C, Schuger C D, Lehmann M H
Division of Cardiology, Harper Hospital, Detroit, MI 48201.
JAMA. 1989 Feb 17;261(7):1013-6.
Hemodynamic stability during wide QRS tachycardia is commonly, albeit erroneously, taken as evidence for a supraventricular mechanism. To determine the magnitude for potential misdiagnosis in applying this notion clinically, we analyzed 20 consecutive cases of regular wide QRS tachycardia in conscious adult patients (mean age, 64 years). The most common heart disease was atherosclerotic (75%), with an associated history of remote myocardial infarction in 73% of the cases. Tachycardia was sustained for a mean of 4.8 hours prior to medical evaluation, with a mean rate of 186 beats per minute and mean systolic blood pressure of 111 mm Hg. A diagnosis of ventricular tachycardia (VT) was established in 17 cases (85%). In the patients with VT, atrioventricular dissociation was recognized on the 12-lead electrocardiogram in 38%, with Wellens' morphological features favoring the diagnosis in 73%. Following conversion to sinus rhythm, electrophysiological testing in 17 patients reproduced the clinical arrhythmia in 94% (with a replication rate of 100% in 15 patients with VT), with at least one additional unsuspected VT morphology induced in 53% of patients with VT. Thus, VT should be considered the most likely cause of regular wide QRS tachycardia in the conscious adult patient, especially with a history of remote myocardial infarction. Recognition of this simple principle and careful examination of the 12-lead electrocardiogram may help to prevent the misapplication of pharmacotherapy in the vast majority of these patients.
宽QRS波心动过速期间的血流动力学稳定性通常(尽管是错误地)被视为室上性机制的证据。为了确定在临床应用这一概念时潜在误诊的程度,我们分析了20例连续的清醒成年患者(平均年龄64岁)的规则宽QRS波心动过速病例。最常见的心脏病是动脉粥样硬化(75%),73%的病例有陈旧性心肌梗死病史。在接受医学评估之前,心动过速平均持续4.8小时,平均心率为每分钟186次,平均收缩压为111 mmHg。17例(85%)确诊为室性心动过速(VT)。在VT患者中,12导联心电图显示房室分离的占38%,Wellens形态学特征支持诊断的占73%。转为窦性心律后,17例患者进行电生理检查,94%再现了临床心律失常(15例VT患者的复制率为100%),53%的VT患者诱发了至少一种额外的未被怀疑的VT形态。因此,VT应被视为清醒成年患者规则宽QRS波心动过速最可能的原因,尤其是有陈旧性心肌梗死病史的患者。认识到这一简单原则并仔细检查12导联心电图可能有助于防止在绝大多数此类患者中错误应用药物治疗。