Schad Friedemann, Thronicke Anja, Merkle Antje, Matthes Harald, Steele Megan L
Research Institute Havelhoehe, Berlin, Germany; Department of Oncology, Hospital Havelhoehe, Berlin, Germany.
Research Institute Havelhoehe, Berlin, Germany.
Phytomedicine. 2017 Dec 1;36:54-58. doi: 10.1016/j.phymed.2017.09.004. Epub 2017 Sep 21.
Immune-related adverse drug reactions (ADRs) to immunotherapy agents have been associated with beneficial clinical outcomes in oncology. Viscum album L. (VA, European mistletoe) is frequently used as an immunomodulatory agent alongside conventional cancer treatment in Europe. VA has been associated with improved quality of life and a reduction in chemotherapy-related ADRs. Beneficial effects of VA are believed to be related to its immunomodulatory properties. Current guidelines recommend commencing with a low dose and increasing slowly overtime, however, off-label prescribing of high initial doses is common.
We investigated ADR profiles related to subcutaneous VA therapy commencing with low, recommended doses versus higher than recommended doses.
Retrospective cohort study.
Medical records of 1361 cancer patients treated between 2003 and 2013 were assessed. Patients were divided into two groups based on whether the dose of their first VA injection adhered to current guidelines. Patient characteristics and suspected VA-related ADRs were compared between dose groups.
Of 1361 cancer patients, 516 (38%) started with a recommended, low dose of VA(≤0.02 mg) and 845 (62%) started with a higher dose(>0.02 mg). Groups did not differ by age or gender, but significant differences were observed for type (p < 0.001) and stage of cancer (p = 0.05). Starting with a high dose of VA was significantly associated with a higher incidence of VA-related ADRs compared to starting with a low dose (20.7% versus 0.8%, p < 0.001). Adjusting for age, gender, tumour type and stage of disease, produced an odds ratio of 37.5 (95% CI = 15.7-122.8, p < .001). Almost all ADRs, irrespective of the initial VA dose, were of mild or moderate intensity. Most ADRs were immune-related, general disorders and administration site conditions, many of which are desired reactions, such as pyrexia and local reactions. Overall, no serious ADRs occurred.
Starting VA therapy with a higher than recommended dose was associated with a high frequency of ADRs, however, nearly all ADRs were expected, of mild to moderate intensity and most were desired reactions. Future research is necessary to investigate whether higher incidences of immune-related events are indicators of beneficial immunomodulation and better clinical outcomes.
免疫治疗药物的免疫相关不良药物反应(ADR)与肿瘤学中的有益临床结果相关。欧洲槲寄生(Viscum album L.,VA)在欧洲常作为免疫调节剂与传统癌症治疗联合使用。VA与生活质量改善及化疗相关ADR减少有关。VA的有益作用被认为与其免疫调节特性有关。目前的指南建议从低剂量开始并随时间缓慢增加剂量,然而,高初始剂量的超说明书用药很常见。
我们研究了与皮下注射VA治疗相关的ADR情况,比较了从低推荐剂量与高于推荐剂量开始治疗的情况。
回顾性队列研究。
评估了2003年至2013年间接受治疗的1361例癌症患者的病历。根据首次VA注射剂量是否符合当前指南,将患者分为两组。比较剂量组之间的患者特征和疑似与VA相关的ADR。
在1361例癌症患者中,516例(38%)从推荐的低剂量VA(≤0.02mg)开始治疗,845例(62%)从高剂量(>0.02mg)开始治疗。两组在年龄或性别上无差异,但在癌症类型(p<0.001)和分期(p=0.05)上观察到显著差异。与从低剂量开始相比,从高剂量开始使用VA与VA相关ADR的发生率显著更高(20.7%对0.8%,p<0.001)。对年龄、性别、肿瘤类型和疾病分期进行调整后,优势比为37.5(95%CI=15.7-122.8,p<0.001)。几乎所有ADR,无论初始VA剂量如何,均为轻度或中度。大多数ADR与免疫相关、属于一般病症和给药部位情况,其中许多是预期反应,如发热和局部反应。总体而言,未发生严重ADR。
以高于推荐剂量开始VA治疗与ADR的高发生率相关,然而,几乎所有ADR都是预期的,为轻度至中度,且大多数是预期反应。未来有必要进行研究,以调查免疫相关事件的较高发生率是否是有益免疫调节和更好临床结果的指标。