Parker Roses, McKeever Stephen, Wiseman Theresa, Twycross Alison
Department of Children's Nursing, School of Health and Social Care, London South Bank University, London, UK; The Royal Marsden NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK.
Department of Children's Nursing, School of Health and Social Care, London South Bank University, London, UK.
Pain Manag Nurs. 2018 Apr;19(2):139-156. doi: 10.1016/j.pmn.2017.10.006. Epub 2017 Nov 22.
To identify interventions aimed at helping parents manage their child's pain at home and to establish which aspects of interventions were effective. Integrative narrative review. MEDLINE, CINAHL Plus, PsychINFO, PsychArticles, AMED, PubMed, Scopus and Web of Knowledge databases were searched in 2016. This narrative synthesis followed Centre for Reviews and Dissemination and Economic and Social Research Council guidance. Reasons attributed to intervention success were analyzed using content analysis. From 2,534 papers, 17 were included. A majority were randomized controlled trials (n = 13) and most addressed postoperative pain (n = 15). A range of interventions were found that directly targeted parents, including child-parent interactions and health care professional-parent interactions, as well as complex interventions. Three studies were successful in reducing child pain at home and seven in increasing appropriate analgesic drug administration. Analysis of reasons attributed to interventions success revealed characteristics of interventions, components of parental pain management, and key features of research that aid researchers in designing and evaluating interventions. Risk of bias was present because of inadequate randomization, lack of a control group, and underpowered studies. Nurses should be aware that targeting parents directly is the most effective way of reducing child pain at home. Nurses need to advocate for effective analgesics for their child patients because the ineffectiveness of many interventions was attributed to inadequate analgesic drugs. Once this is achieved, success in increasing analgesic drug administration is most likely reached via parent-targeted interventions and those targeting health care professional-parent interactions. Successful interventions will be tailored to the child and adequately powered. Including a measure of sedation will ensure sedation is not mistaken for analgesic effectiveness. Interventions should address multiple facets of pain management and include a measure of pain over a period as opposed to a snapshot in time.
确定旨在帮助家长在家中管理孩子疼痛的干预措施,并确定干预措施的哪些方面是有效的。综合叙述性综述。2016年检索了MEDLINE、CINAHL Plus、PsychINFO、PsychArticles、AMED、PubMed、Scopus和Web of Knowledge数据库。本叙述性综述遵循了综述与传播中心以及经济和社会研究委员会的指导方针。采用内容分析法分析干预成功的原因。从2534篇论文中,纳入了17篇。大多数是随机对照试验(n = 13),且大多数涉及术后疼痛(n = 15)。发现了一系列直接针对家长的干预措施,包括儿童与家长的互动以及医护人员与家长的互动,还有复杂干预措施。三项研究成功减少了孩子在家中的疼痛,七项研究成功增加了适当镇痛药的使用。对干预成功原因的分析揭示了干预措施的特点、家长疼痛管理的组成部分以及有助于研究人员设计和评估干预措施的研究关键特征。由于随机化不足、缺乏对照组和研究效能不足,存在偏倚风险。护士应意识到直接针对家长是减少孩子在家中疼痛的最有效方法。护士需要为其儿童患者争取有效的镇痛药,因为许多干预措施无效归因于镇痛药不足。一旦做到这一点,通过针对家长的干预措施以及针对医护人员与家长互动的干预措施,最有可能在增加镇痛药使用方面取得成功。成功的干预措施将根据孩子的情况进行调整并有足够的效能。纳入镇静测量将确保不会将镇静误认为是镇痛效果。干预措施应涉及疼痛管理的多个方面,并包括一段时间内的疼痛测量,而不是某个时间点的快照。