Atnafu Asfaw, Otto Kate, Herbst Christopher H
Center for e-Health, College of Health Sciences, Addis Ababa University, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
The World Bank, African Regional Technical Health Unit, Washington, DC, USA.
Mhealth. 2017 Sep 14;3:39. doi: 10.21037/mhealth.2017.08.04. eCollection 2017.
The provision of consistent and quality maternal and child health (MCH) services is a challenge for Ethiopia where most of the population lives in the rural setup. Health service delivery is constrained mainly by shortage of health professionals, meager resources, limited awareness among the society and bureaucratic procedures. Low health service utilization of antenatal care (ANC), delivery services, and postnatal care (PNC) are believed to contribute for high maternal and child mortality rates. Innovative approach like mHealth based technological intervention believed to alleviate such challenges in countries like ours. However, currently, there are few evidences that demonstrate the impact of mHealth technology applications on the level of service utilization. Therefore, the objective our study is to assess the role of mobile phone equipped with short message service (SMS) based data-exchange software linking community health workers to Health Centers in rural Ethiopia affect selected MCH outcomes.
A community-based randomized control trial (RCT) was conducted in three woredas of Guraghe zone (Ezha, partial &Abeshge full intervention, Sodo Control). Mobile phones equipped with FrontlineSMS based, locally developed application was distributed to all health extension workers (HEWs) to both intervention woredas who filled maternal, child and stock related forms and submitted to the central server which in turn sends reminder about the scheduled date of ANC visit, expected date of delivery, PNC, immunization schedule and vaccine and contraceptive stock status. Moreover, in Abeshge, the voluntary health workers (vCHW) and HEW supervisors in both intervention woreda were given a phone to facilitate communication with the HEW. No mobile was offered to the control woreda.Pre [2012] and post [2013] intervention community based survey on mothers who have under 5 and under 1 year old child was done to assess the effect of the mobile intervention on selected MCH process indicators. Structured and pretested questionnaire was used to collect data and SPSS v16 statistical software was used for analysis.
Three thousand two hundred and forty mothers, 1,080 from each, were surveyed in the three woredas. The study revealed that the proportion of mothers receiving more than four ANC visits increased significantly in both intervention woredas. Besides, the rate of ANC delivered by HEWs improved in Ezha woreda (T1) (19.01% to 28.27%), proportions of deliveries attended by skilled health workers increased and home delivery decreased in all woredas; most pronounced increases in referrals from health post to health center by HEWs, reported in Ezha and Abeshge. The intervention also led to a significant reduction in stock-outs of preferred contraceptive products in Ezha (T1) from 16.96% to 8.24% but no change was observed in both contraceptive prevalence and immunization rates in the control and the other intervention woreda.
The study confirmed the positive contribution of SMS based mobile phone intervention in most of the selected MCH service indicators, like improvement in the percent of recommended number of ANC visit, percentage of delivery attended by health workers and facilitating the work processes of the health workers in rural Ethiopia.
对于埃塞俄比亚而言,提供持续且高质量的母婴健康(MCH)服务是一项挑战,该国大部分人口生活在农村地区。卫生服务的提供主要受到卫生专业人员短缺、资源匮乏、社会认知有限以及官僚程序的制约。产前保健(ANC)、分娩服务和产后保健(PNC)的卫生服务利用率较低,据信这是导致母婴死亡率居高不下的原因之一。像基于移动健康(mHealth)的技术干预这样的创新方法,被认为能够缓解我们这样的国家所面临的此类挑战。然而,目前几乎没有证据表明mHealth技术应用对服务利用率水平产生的影响。因此,我们研究的目的是评估配备基于短信服务(SMS)的数据交换软件、将社区卫生工作者与埃塞俄比亚农村地区的健康中心相连接的手机,对选定的母婴健康结果的影响。
在古拉格地区的三个区(埃扎、部分及阿贝什格全干预、索多对照)开展了一项基于社区的随机对照试验(RCT)。为所有卫生推广工作者(HEW)配备了装有基于FrontlineSMS的本地开发应用程序的手机,这些工作者分布在两个干预区,他们填写母婴及库存相关表格并提交至中央服务器,中央服务器反过来会发送关于产前检查预定日期、预产期、产后检查、免疫接种计划以及疫苗和避孕药具库存状态的提醒。此外,在阿贝什格,两个干预区的志愿卫生工作者(vCHW)和卫生推广工作者监督员都配备了手机,以方便与卫生推广工作者进行沟通。对照区未配备手机。在干预前[2012年]和干预后[2013年],对有5岁以下和1岁以下儿童的母亲进行了基于社区的调查,以评估移动干预对选定的母婴健康过程指标的影响。使用结构化且经过预测试的问卷收集数据,并使用SPSS v16统计软件进行分析。
在这三个区共对3240名母亲进行了调查,每个区1080名。研究表明,在两个干预区,接受四次以上产前检查的母亲比例显著增加。此外,埃扎区(T1)由卫生推广工作者接生的产前检查比例有所提高(从19.01%提高到28.27%),所有区由熟练卫生工作者接生的比例增加,家庭分娩比例下降;在埃扎和阿贝什格,卫生推广工作者从卫生站转诊至健康中心的情况增加最为明显。该干预还导致埃扎区(T1)首选避孕产品的缺货情况从16.96%显著降至8.24%,但对照区和另一个干预区的避孕普及率和免疫接种率均未发生变化。
该研究证实了基于短信的手机干预在大多数选定的母婴健康服务指标方面的积极贡献,如提高产前检查推荐次数的百分比、卫生工作者接生的分娩百分比以及促进埃塞俄比亚农村地区卫生工作者的工作流程。