Cacioppo J C, Diettrich N A, Kaplan G, Nora P F
Department of Surgery, Columbus Hospital, Chicago, Illinois.
Am J Surg. 1989 Mar;157(3):276-81. doi: 10.1016/0002-9610(89)90549-7.
In this study, we sought to identify changes in the picture of a selected surgical condition during an interval of time that has brought about radical departures from previously established policies and programs. As a direct consequence, the patients take a more circuitous route to the surgeon. A significant number of patients with acute appendicitis in 1986 (37 percent) and 1987 (29 percent) suffered a prolonged delay in hospitalization or surgical referral compared with patients in 1980. This delay was accompanied by a more advanced stage of disease that ultimately caused a markedly increased morbidity (13 percent in 1986 and 24 percent in 1987, compared with 5 percent in 1980) and subsequent extended length of stay. This deterioration in patient care and failure at cost containment had previously been examined for conditions that can be operated electively. This study documents that the constraints also affect the treatment of patients whose initial condition requires urgent operative treatment. With specific relation to patients with acute appendicitis, surgeons recognize the value of the negative appendectomy. It appears the so-called gatekeepers must find a way to accept a certain negative hospitalization to referral rate. If current constraints will not allow this, the policies and programs behind the constraints should be changed.
在本研究中,我们试图确定在一段时期内选定外科疾病情况的变化,这段时期带来了与先前既定政策和项目的根本性背离。直接后果是,患者就医过程变得更为曲折。与1980年的患者相比,1986年(37%)和1987年(29%)有相当数量的急性阑尾炎患者在住院或手术转诊方面出现了长时间延迟。这种延迟伴随着疾病进展到更严重阶段,最终导致发病率显著上升(1986年为13%,1987年为24%,而1980年为5%)以及随后住院时间延长。此前已针对可择期手术的疾病情况对患者护理的这种恶化以及成本控制失败进行过研究。本研究证明,这些限制因素也会影响对初始病情需要紧急手术治疗的患者的治疗。具体就急性阑尾炎患者而言,外科医生认识到阴性阑尾切除术的价值。看来所谓的把关人必须找到一种方法来接受一定的阴性住院转诊率。如果当前的限制因素不允许这样做,那么限制因素背后的政策和项目就应该改变。