Neumann A C, McCarty G R, Sanders D R, Raanan M G
Neumann Eye Institute, DeLand, Florida 32720.
J Cataract Refract Surg. 1989 Jan;15(1):78-84. doi: 10.1016/s0886-3350(89)80144-0.
Astigmatic changes in three series of cataract surgical procedures were compared. Two series comprised eyes having phacoemulsification and implantation of a foldable silicone lens through a 3.0 mm to 4.0 mm incision or a 5.8 mm diameter polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) lens through a 6.0 mm incision. The third series comprised eyes having a planned extracapsular cataract extraction (ECCE) procedure through a 10.0 mm incision and implantation of a PMMA posterior chamber lens. Surgically induced cylinder changes were compared by examining preoperative and postoperative dioptric cylinder power changes without regard to axis changes and by using vector analysis to compute induced cylinder for cases with axis changes. Both phacoemulsification series had similar mean induced cylinder levels, which were significantly less than mean induced cylinder in the ECCE group at both three and six months after surgery. Over 70% of the eyes in the two small incision phacoemulsification groups achieved an uncorrected visual acuity of 20/40 or better at three months, whereas only 28% of the ECCE group achieved that acuity. We concluded that the phacoemulsification procedure induced significantly less astigmatism and provided faster visual rehabilitation than the ECCE procedure. Furthermore, the use of small diameter PMMA IOLs inserted through small incisions minimized surgically induced cylinder in a way comparable to the use of foldable silicone implants, while maintaining good visual results with fewer postoperative complications.
比较了三组白内障手术中的散光变化。两组采用超声乳化术,通过3.0毫米至4.0毫米切口植入可折叠硅胶晶状体,或通过6.0毫米切口植入直径5.8毫米的聚甲基丙烯酸甲酯(PMMA)晶状体。第三组采用计划中的囊外白内障摘除术(ECCE),通过10.0毫米切口并植入PMMA后房型晶状体。通过检查术前和术后屈光柱镜度数变化(不考虑轴位变化)以及使用矢量分析计算轴位变化病例的诱导柱镜,比较手术引起的柱镜变化。两个超声乳化术组的平均诱导柱镜水平相似,在术后三个月和六个月时均显著低于ECCE组的平均诱导柱镜。两个小切口超声乳化术组中超过70%的眼睛在三个月时裸眼视力达到20/40或更好,而ECCE组只有28%的眼睛达到该视力。我们得出结论,与ECCE手术相比,超声乳化手术引起的散光明显更少,视觉恢复更快。此外,通过小切口插入小直径PMMA人工晶状体可将手术引起的柱镜降至最低,其效果与使用可折叠硅胶植入物相当,同时保持良好的视觉效果且术后并发症更少。