Serrao Graziano, Tassoni Massimo, Magenta-Biasina Alberto M, Mantero Antonio Giuseppe, Previtera Antonino, Turci Michela Crisitna, Biganzoli Elia Mario, Bertolini Emanuela A M
Università degli Studi di Milano, Department of Health Sciences, Milan, Italy.
Azienda Ospedaliera San Paolo, Radiology, Milan, Italy.
Ultrasound Int Open. 2017 Sep;3(4):E156-E162. doi: 10.1055/s-0043-121983. Epub 2017 Dec 7.
The aim of the present study was to assess the educational plan of first-year students of medicine by analyzing their scores in ultrasound body scanning.
Since 2009, the San Paolo Medical School (Milan, Italy) has vertically integrated the study of anatomy with ultrasound-assisted virtual body dissection. Three modules were supplied: musculoskeletal system, heart and abdomen pelvis. 653 first-year students were trained. The students alternated as mutual model and operator. A skillfulness score was assigned to each student. The scores were consequently listed. Nonparametric exact multiple contrast tests were employed to determine relative group effects.
Statistical analysis showed that: no gender-related differences were found (0:49; p=0.769); peer learners performed less well than peer tutors (0.677; p=0); between modules, scores in the musculoskeletal system (pMS=0.726) tend to be higher (p<0.001) than those obtained in the heart and abdomen pelvis (pH=0.398; pAP=0.375 p=0.270); significant differences were found compared to the beginning of the project's academic year.
The students considered this didactic course an engaging and exciting approach. Acceptance of peer teaching was extraordinarily high. Autonomous exercitation allowed the students to improve self-criticism and enhance their own skills. The level of expertise obtained by peer tutors and by peer learners can be considered satisfactory. The main objective of training future physicians on personal stethoechoscope with the necessary competence seems to have been successfully started.
本研究旨在通过分析医学专业一年级学生的超声人体扫描成绩来评估其教育计划。
自2009年以来,圣保罗医学院(意大利米兰)将解剖学研究与超声辅助虚拟人体解剖进行了纵向整合。提供了三个模块:肌肉骨骼系统、心脏和腹部骨盆。对653名一年级学生进行了培训。学生们交替担任相互的模型和操作者。为每个学生分配了一个熟练程度分数。随后列出了分数。采用非参数精确多重对比检验来确定相对组效应。
统计分析表明:未发现性别相关差异(0:49;p = 0.769);同伴学习者的表现不如同伴辅导者(0.677;p = 0);在各模块之间,肌肉骨骼系统的分数(pMS = 0.726)往往高于心脏和腹部骨盆的分数(pH = 0.398;pAP = 0.375,p = 0.270)(p < 0.001);与项目学年开始时相比发现了显著差异。
学生们认为这一教学课程是一种引人入胜且令人兴奋的方法。同伴教学的接受度非常高。自主练习使学生能够提高自我批评能力并提升自身技能。同伴辅导者和同伴学习者获得的专业水平可被认为是令人满意的。培养未来医生使用个人听诊器并具备必要能力的主要目标似乎已成功启动。