Ellenberg Eytan, Taragin Mark I, Hoffman Jay R, Cohen Osnat, Luft-Afik Danielle, Bar-On Zvia, Ostfeld Ishay
National Insurance Institute of Israel.
University of Central Florida.
Milbank Q. 2017 Dec;95(4):783-800. doi: 10.1111/1468-0009.12299.
Policy Points: Across the globe, the threat from terrorist attacks is rising, which requires a careful assessment of long-term medical support. We found 3 major sources of costs: hospital expenditures, mental health services dedicated to acute stress reactions, and ambulatory follow-up. During the first year, most of the costs were related to hospitalization and support for stress relief. During the second year, ambulatory and rehabilitation costs continued to grow. Public health specialists should consider these major components of costs and their evolution over time to properly advise the medical and social authorities on allocating resources for the medical and nonmedical support of civilian casualties resulting from war or terror.
Across the globe, the threat from terrorist attacks is rising, which requires a careful assessment of long-term medical support. Based on an 18-month follow-up of the Israeli civilian population following the 2014 war in Gaza, we describe and analyze the medical costs associated with rocket attacks and review the demography of the victims who filed claims for disability compensation. We then propose practical lessons to help health care authorities prepare for future confrontations.
Using the National Insurance Institute of Israel's (NII) database, we conducted descriptive and comparative analyses using statistical tests (Fisher's Exact Test, chi-square test, and students' t-tests). The costs were updated until March 30, 2016, and are presented in US dollars. We included only civilian expenses in our analysis.
We identified 5,189 victims, 3,236 of whom presented with acute stress reactions during the conflict. Eighteen months after the conflict, the victims' total medical costs reached $4.4 million. The NII reimbursed $2,541,053 for associated medical costs and $1,921,792 for associated mental health costs. A total of 709 victims filed claims with the NII for further support, including rehabilitation, medical devices, and disability pensions.
We found 3 major sources of costs: hospital expenditures, mental health services dedicated to acute stress reactions, and ambulatory follow-up. During the first year, most of the costs were related to hospitalization and support for stress relief. During the second year, ambulatory and rehabilitation costs continued to grow. Public health specialists should consider these major components of costs and their evolution over time to properly advise the medical and social authorities on allocating resources for the medical and nonmedical support of civilian casualties resulting from war or terror.
政策要点:在全球范围内,恐怖袭击的威胁日益增加,这需要对长期医疗支持进行仔细评估。我们发现了3个主要成本来源:医院支出、针对急性应激反应的心理健康服务以及门诊随访。在第一年,大部分成本与住院治疗和缓解压力的支持有关。在第二年,门诊和康复成本持续增长。公共卫生专家应考虑这些主要成本构成及其随时间的变化,以便就为战争或恐怖事件导致的平民伤亡提供医疗和非医疗支持分配资源的问题,向医疗和社会当局提供恰当建议。
在全球范围内,恐怖袭击的威胁日益增加,这需要对长期医疗支持进行仔细评估。基于对2014年加沙战争后以色列平民人口进行的18个月随访,我们描述并分析了与火箭弹袭击相关的医疗成本,并审查了申请残疾赔偿的受害者的人口统计学特征。然后,我们提出实用的经验教训,以帮助医疗保健当局为未来的冲突做好准备。
利用以色列国家保险协会(NII)的数据库,我们使用统计检验(费舍尔精确检验、卡方检验和学生t检验)进行描述性和比较性分析。成本更新至2016年3月30日,并以美元呈现。我们的分析仅包括平民费用。
我们确定了5189名受害者,其中3236人在冲突期间出现急性应激反应。冲突18个月后,受害者的医疗总成本达到440万美元。NII为相关医疗成本报销了2541053美元,为相关心理健康成本报销了1921792美元。共有709名受害者向NII提出进一步支持的索赔,包括康复、医疗设备和残疾抚恤金。
我们发现了3个主要成本来源:医院支出、针对急性应激反应的心理健康服务以及门诊随访。在第一年,大部分成本与住院治疗和缓解压力的支持有关。在第二年,门诊和康复成本持续增长。公共卫生专家应考虑这些主要成本构成及其随时间的变化,以便就为战争或恐怖事件导致的平民伤亡提供医疗和非医疗支持分配资源的问题,向医疗和社会当局提供恰当建议。