Lea Bonner C, Staton April G, Naro Patricia B, McCullough Elizabeth, Lynn Stevenson T, Williamson Margaret, Sheffield Melody C, Miller Mindi, Fetterman James W, Fan Shirley, Momary Kathryn M
Mercer University College of Pharmacy, 3001 Mercer University Drive, Atlanta, GA 30341, United States.
Auburn University Harrison School of Pharmacy, 1202 Walker Building, Auburn, AL 36849, United States.
Curr Pharm Teach Learn. 2018 Jan-Feb;10(1):14-20. doi: 10.1016/j.cptl.2017.09.010. Epub 2017 Oct 11.
Experiential pharmacy preceptors should provide formative and summative feedback during a learning experience. Preceptors are required to provide colleges and schools of pharmacy with assessments or evaluations of students' performance. Students and experiential programs value on-time completion of midpoint evaluations by preceptors. The objective of this study was to determine the number of on-time electronically documented formative midpoint evaluations completed by preceptors during advanced pharmacy practice experiences (APPEs).
Compliance rates of on-time electronically documented formative midpoint evaluations were reviewed by the Office of Experiential Education of a five-member consortium during the two-year study period prior to the adoption of Standards 2016. Pearson chi-square test and generalized linear models were used to determine if statistically significant differences were present.
Average midpoint compliance rates for the two-year research period were 40.7% and 41% respectively. No statistical significance was noted comparing compliance rates for year one versus year two. However, statistical significance was present when comparing compliance rates between schools during year two. Feedback from students and preceptors pointed to the need for brief formal midpoint evaluations that require minimal time to complete, user friendly experiential management software, and methods for documenting verbal feedback through student self-reflection.
Additional education and training to both affiliate and faculty preceptors on the importance of written formative feedback at midpoint is critical to remaining in compliance with Standards 2016.
实践带教教师应在学习过程中提供形成性和总结性反馈。带教教师需要向药学院校提供学生表现的评估。学生和实践项目重视带教教师按时完成中期评估。本研究的目的是确定在高级药学实践经验(APPEs)期间带教教师按时以电子方式记录的形成性中期评估的数量。
在采用2016年标准之前的两年研究期间,一个由五所院校组成的联盟的实践教育办公室审查了按时以电子方式记录的形成性中期评估的合规率。使用Pearson卡方检验和广义线性模型来确定是否存在统计学上的显著差异。
两年研究期间的平均中期合规率分别为40.7%和41%。比较第一年和第二年的合规率时未发现统计学显著性。然而,在比较第二年各学校之间的合规率时存在统计学显著性。学生和带教教师的反馈表明,需要简短的正式中期评估,这些评估需要最少的时间来完成,需要用户友好的实践管理软件,以及通过学生自我反思记录口头反馈的方法。
对附属带教教师和教师带教教师进行关于中期书面形成性反馈重要性的额外教育和培训,对于遵守2016年标准至关重要。