Mercer University College of Pharmacy, Atlanta, Georgia.
Am J Pharm Educ. 2020 Oct;84(10):ajpe7853. doi: 10.5688/ajpe7853.
To evaluate levels of entrustability and practice readiness in advanced pharmacy practice experience (APPE) students using a pilot instrument designed to assess their competency in performing the entrustable professional activities (EPAs) expected of new pharmacy graduates. A pilot instrument was developed directly from EPAs to measure entrustability levels on a scale of one to five. Five APPE preceptors from several different practice areas participated. Fourth-year students used the instrument to self-evaluate their knowledge and skills at the beginning, midpoint, and end of the APPE. The preceptors evaluated students using the same instrument at APPE midpoint and end. The instrument had assigned weights for each EPA and entrustability level for a score of 100 if all items were marked five. If a rating of non-applicable was chosen, score adjustments were made. All students in the graduating class of 2018 were invited to perform a self-evaluation at the end of the fourth (APPE) year using the same instrument that study participants used. Twenty-eight students and five preceptors completed evaluations during the APPE year. Overall scores from both preceptor evaluations of students and student self-evaluations increased significantly from pre-APPE to midpoint to final. Student self-evaluations were only slightly higher than preceptor evaluations. The mean (SD) preceptor scores for students and student self-assessment scores at the end of each APPE were 85.4% (7.1) and 87.2% (10.3), respectfully. One practice manager EPA and three population health EPAs were considered to not be applicable by preceptors on ≥50% of evaluations. Approximately 94% of all graduating students completed the year-end self-evaluations, with a mean (SD) score of 89% (8.6) and no EPAs marked as not applicable. Pharmacy students' proficiency in EPA improved during individual APPEs. According to preceptors, students' greatest improvement in entrustability was in educating patients and colleagues regarding appropriate use of medications and collecting information to identify medication-related problems.
为了使用专门设计的评估工具来评估高级药学实践经验 (APPE) 学生的可委托性和实践准备程度,该工具旨在评估他们执行新药学毕业生预期的可委托专业活动 (EPA) 的能力。 一个试点工具是直接从 EPA 开发出来的,以一到五的等级来衡量可委托性水平。来自几个不同实践领域的五位 APPE 导师参与了研究。第四年的学生在 APPE 的开始、中点和结束时使用该工具对自己的知识和技能进行自我评估。导师在 APPE 中点和结束时使用相同的工具评估学生。该工具为每个 EPA 和可委托性水平分配了权重,如果所有项目都标记为五,则得分为 100。如果选择了不适用的评级,则进行评分调整。2018 届所有毕业生都被邀请在第四年 (APPE) 结束时使用与研究参与者相同的工具进行自我评估。 28 名学生和 5 名导师在 APPE 年度期间完成了评估。学生的导师评估和学生自我评估的总分从 APPE 前到中点到最终都显著增加。学生的自我评估仅略高于导师的评估。每个 APPE 结束时导师对学生的平均(SD)评分和学生自我评估分数分别为 85.4%(7.1)和 87.2%(10.3)。在所有评估中,有 1 个实践经理 EPA 和 3 个人群健康 EPA 被导师认为不适用的比例≥50%。大约 94%的所有应届毕业生都完成了年终自我评估,平均(SD)得分为 89%(8.6),没有任何 EPA 被标记为不适用。 药学学生在个别 APPE 中的 EPA 熟练程度有所提高。根据导师的说法,学生在委托方面最大的进步是教育患者和同事正确使用药物以及收集信息以确定与药物相关的问题。